Buzzing spot with old-world charm, serving Italian small plates & wood-fired thin crust pizza. Based on 483 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
558 Bishop Rd, Highland Heights, OH 44143
Phone: (440) 449-7800
Website: http://www.crostatas.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daniel DeCost
Ever try a restaurant for the first time and when you first read through the menu you’re excited to come back before you even have the first bite?
… more
Lisa L
I used to enjoy coming here, but will not be back. I haven’t been here in over a year and wow, what a difference. I think it’s under new ownership, but not sure. It’s dirty looking. The menus are all worn out where you can’t read a lot of things on them. Our server was a little bit overbearing with her suggestions and the food wasn’t good. I do not recommend the stuffed artichoke. It had zero flavor. The wine was old and bitter tasting. Try someplace else.
… more
Lauren OJanpa
I love this restaurant. It’s the best Italian food I’ve eaten and maybe food for that matter with how fresh and perfected it tasted. My boyfriend and I ordered 3 desserts and 2 small pizzas and salad. It’s magical here and we’ll be back soon.
… more
avinash ekhar
Nice place but very busy. Taste is good but little costly.
… more
Chris Gallagher
I hadn’t been here in a while due to the pandemic. Came back when my wife found it on Google Maps when we were in the area — she’d never been.
… more
Christopher Young
The Best Authentic Sicilian Italian Italian Food on Planet Earth. End of the story. Everything is prepared as if your Grandmother was making it just for you on a Sunday afternoon. FRESH and the very finest ingredients money can buy. You’d be hard pressed to find any Italian Restaurant anywhere unless you got on an International Flight to Italy that comes close. From the Caesar Salad, stone oven pizzas topped with fresh basil, stuffed artichokes, zucchini planks, ravioli, chicken breast cutlets, meat balls & sausage, to the desserts it’s all GREAT!! The service is also excellent making sure your happy with your meal, and checking to see if there is anything you might need in regards to what you are drinking. The whole restaurant including the restrooms are SPOTLESS! Give this one of a kind authentic Italian restaurant your money you won’t every be disappointed. Consistent quality time after time.
… more
Maria Thomas Green
We used to live closer to Crostadas and would go more frequently. We now live on the west side, so it isn’t as convenient to get there. We miss it. When we had a tour scheduled at the Holden Arboretum one morning, I knew what we were going to do for lunch! We had a calamari appetizer that was absolutely fantastic, pizzas (4 cheese, mushroom) and dessert (gelato, a chocolate torte and a lemon torte). I am now happy until I can figure out another reason to be on that side of town.
… more
Merrell Sheehan
Always wanted to try Crostatas and tonight I did. Cozy little place which was surprising since it looks bigger from the street. The food was great … the salads are more than enough for 2 … and the Zucchini slices/fries were honestly the best I have ever had.
… more
Kevin Petrak
I have lived here for 11+ years and have been meaning to try Crostatas. Finally decided to give it a try and wow, were we disappointed.
… more
smautobody
We walked in at 8:20 and was greeted by a rude host telling us they were closed. I said I thought you were open till 9 pm on a Friday night, said the kitchen was already cleaning up. Then she checked with someone and said she could seat us, but we have to be done by 9:00. I told her to forget it. I will Never go back there and would never recommend to anyone
… more
… View more