Damon’s is a Premium quality pizza restaurant offering Dine-in, Delivery and Carry-out.
We only source the highest quality cheeses, tomato products and ingredients in our award winning Pizzas!
We offer over 40 Oven Baked Subs!
We offer Pastas, Salads, Gyros, Wedge Sandwiches and more!
Based on 150 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
306 B, 306 S College St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832
Phone: (740) 498-5600
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mary Service
Wow awesome crust, good sauce, generous toppings, yummy cheese and piping hot!! We were driving to Hocking Hills from the Canton area and wanted to grab a pizza on our way. The pizza shop is on an old building, but don’t judge a book by its cover. What a wonderful surprise!!
… more
Evan Horne
You know the saying,”better late than never”? This place has a tendency to choose never. Placed an order and was told 25min. Still waiting for that order to this day. A simple call would’ve been nice
… more
Cindy Hunt
I have ordered food here for yrs now & always liked their food. Recently we ordered boneless wings & was very disappointed how small they were, the smallest wings ever, but they were still the same price as they’ve been for awhile, so a couple of nights ago we ordered wings but with the bone in, well my husband called & picked up the order. He came home & told me they doubled the price of their wings! For 20 wings & an order of Mexican sticks was $56!!!! I asked him if they told him when ordering the prices doubled & he said no & I told him then he should’ve told them to keep them cuz I wouldn’t have paid that much!!! There is no shortage on chickens!! Plenty of other places have wings that aren’t charging that much!!! The wings are small too!! Go to Rooster’s sometime to see what wings should look like!!! If I ever order here again I’ll NEVER order the wings!!! I know my co-workers & others have quit ordering here because of the prices. It’s a shame because it is a locally owned business & they do have good food.
… more
Bold Heart (Boldheart)
Good, but only if you like sweet marinara sauce. Sweetest I’ve ever had
… more
Zoie Cole
Ordered a salad and boneless wings was told 20-25 minutes for delivery waited over and hour and a half and still no food. I called 6 times no answer. How disappointing and rude.
… more
Wildcards Rex
This was my first time eating at Damon’s. My wife is from Newcomerstown and she’s talked about their pizza for years. We finally went after a trick-or-treat event and got two pizzas. The 5th Inning pizza was really good. Too bad I had to share, haha.
… more
Rebecca Ickes
Waited 25minutes on a 15 minute order . Sub was cold , cheese wasn’t even melted.Hey but my cheese was melted on my salad. Tried to call in order but over and went to voice mail.
… more
Helene2198
My favorite pizza place in eastern Ohio ! Delicious pizza , great wing flavors and awesome hoagies !
… more
Anonymous 1
We ordered pizza for lunch.
… more
Kristi Jones
Called in to place an order, lady who answered was very rude. I’m sorry your having a rough night with 2 new employee’s. You mentioned how you were busy and and other people on hold….. You said” you didn’t have time to wait for me to get the address and phone number”. Well dear, I was ordering from a house who was a friend of a friend. I didnt know the lady’s number or address. As a current and 20 year veteran of food service, your rude behavior will not get you return customers. It also does not show your new hires how you wish to run your business. I will not be back. Even though I have been a fan of your food for over a decade!
… more
… View more