Based on 71 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
17 Columbus St, Auburn, NY 13021
Phone: (315) 253-6888
Website: http://detomasopizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 2–9 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Aaron Forjone
So I finally got around to trying their pizza, pretty good, solid, one pizza weighs a few pounds easy. Nice crispy cheesy crust. Thick sauce, lil zest. I prefer a sweet sauce but it was good. The honey garlic wings were great. Two slices and a few wings hit the spot for me.
… more
Steve Gonzalez
Finally stopped,and ordered a pizza. Been wanting to try them for awhile. My brother tried them a couple of years ago,and said the pizza was tasty!! So I figured I had to try!! Who doesn’t love a deep dish pizza?? So when I got it home. Boy let me tell ya it was delicious!!! You can just tell by the pic I included. I’ll be going back!!! I’m a fan!!!
… more
MyNameIs E
I have never had the worst pizza in my life. I just picked it up and it’s disgusting. The dough is definitely frozen, I asked for light crush red they put a ton, that can be over came but this is honestly the worst pizza I’ve ever seen. Definitely never deserves a 5 star. gross. $19 for this? Would love a refund.
… more
Miss Kelly gramma
We wanted to try this pizza as have great reviews. Had to meet the delivery driver at the end of our driveway cause “I didn’t know how to walk all the food & drinks up the driveway “.. missing an extra Bleu cheese ($1.00 xtra). Wings were very well done, some a little extra & the pizza had waaayy too much oregano. Tried & probably won’t order again.
… more
Robert Reynolds
This place is a hidden gem in the Victor/Farmington area and definitely our go-to for deep dish. The one star reviewer who clearly tore up his pizza in order to defame this small business is a piece of work. I’ve ordered from these folks plenty and my pizzas arrive as seen in my photo every time. They taste delicious and the ingredients they use are amazing. I agree a little pricey, but you can see the time/ingredients put into each pizza are high value. I don’t usually review places, I think this may be my first — but I hope our community discovers this wonderful family owned unique pizza shop so that they stick around for a long time! Seriously every other place in the Victor area I’ve tried is the same generic slice. DeTomaso’s is really onto something.
… more
Sean A (Exorene)
Awful service, keep in mind restaurant was mostly empty, the server told us that a pizza would take an hour to serve, then left us to order, 15 minutes we waited (KNOWING THIS PIZZA WOULD TAKE AN HOUR) in an almost empty restaurant and we weren’t even asked what we wanted to drink while the server kept passing by us while we were trying to get her attention. We left. Would never go back again.
… more
Kristine Crimi
We’ve never eaten at this restaurant before so we decided to give it a try and scheduled a delivery. We ordered 2 pizzas. One plain cheese and one Hawaiian. When it arrived it had 1/4 inch of greece on the top. The edges were burned and tasted burned not caramelized as they told us. The crust was tough and tasteless. When we called to complain, we were given several excuses. One being that we don’t know what authentic Italian food is. The best they offered was a $5 coupon for $50 down the drain because the pizza was tossed in the garbage. I’m 100 percent Italian and have been to Italy several times. This is not authentic Italian pizza in any way shape or form. Will not be returning and will definitely steer everyone I know away from this overpriced garbage.
… more
K13 M88
You’re a pizza place,why don’t you have things for slices i.e. grated cheese,crushed peppers. Garlic powder. Also, the slices are tiny. I can for the same price in Rochester get one slice that’s bigger than three of your slices put together. The pepperoni wasn’t even cooked with the pizza,it was put on after the fact.
… more
Mindy Wade
When I heard these guys were moving to Auburn I was immediately filled with excitement because pizza is my favorite.. social media was filled with positive comments about the quality of their food.. I have to say I tried their pizza for the first time yesterday and they did not disappoint me. It was amazing. Also the staff is amazing. Very friendly!
… more
Tiffany Thrall
My boyfriend and I get DeTomaso’s pizza and wings almost weekly. Should I be ashamed to say that ? Probably. Am I ? Nope.
… more
… View more