No-frills pizza joint with stone-baked pies, plus sub sandwiches, Italian entrees & stromboli. Based on 429 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5283 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228
Phone: (614) 878-7110
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–11 PM |
| Thursday | 3–11 PM |
| Friday | 3 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 3 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 3–11 PM |
| Monday | 3–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kathryn Haden
Interesting pizza. Not bad but very rubbery cheese. Almost too sweet for pizza. Otherwise quick service!
… more
Barbette Pullins
Little place on the west side Columbus!!
… more
Amber Dishman
My family and I tried Don Gino’s pizza on West broad Street last night for the first time and we were all pleasantly surprised. Their sauce and cheese are the real standouts for us. Their sauce is not too sweet or tangy but actually taste like it was seasoned well with garlic and Italian seasoning, the cheese is so delicious and flavorful and they are not stingy with it .The thick crust dough on the pep and cheese was a little sweet which balanced out the sauce and we all really loved it. Their garlic cheesy bread was delicious and only half of that made it home. The wings were okay, we just prefer ours breaded and the fries were actually really good with the pizza. Staff was friendly and our pizza was ready for pickup on time Also their ranch is sooo delicious. We will for sure be back.
… more
Dawn XX
The pizza and Stromboli were delicious! Great, friendly service. This isn’t a dine-in place, take out only but the best Stromboli I’ve ever had.
… more
rejinFN
Pizza was paper thin very hard , crispy and crunchy. Subs was good. They must have doubled there prices because I paid and arm and a leg.This is all left overs because no one really liked the pizzas.
… more
Julianna DeGroat-Träger
Been over 20 years since I was here, it was called Antolinos and the New Rome Police were stilling gunning across the street. Very pleased to say that the name may have changed but the pizza and its quality have not. Delicious pizza and a large for less than $20. Thank you Don Gino.
… more
MRBARBQ 1
Decided to check out Don Gino’s Pizza tonight. Val-Pak coupon special of a 14” One item Pizza and a Garlic Bread with cheese for $14.95. Very good deal. We had the pepperoni which was a coarse meaty type, it had a nice layer of cheese on it. The sauce was a really fresh tasting tomato based sauce. Yummmy!! The garlic cheese bread was really loaded with cheese and a nice garlic flavor to it. Counter gentleman was super nice even with the temperature over 90 degrees. Will have to try again for sure.
… more
Kyriya
Our first time ordering from Don Gino’s and I’m so glad we did. We ordered a cheese and pepperoni, both with extra cheese. Absolutely amazing. The sauce isn’t super sweet like a lot of the chain places, and extra cheese was really extra cheese. The pepperoni has a slight kick to it, which I love. And the crust was cooked to perfection. We had it delivered and it was hot and came quite quickly. Overall, very pleased and we will definitely be ordering again in the future.
… more
Kimberly D
Pizza here is delicious and so are the subs! This is classic “Columbus Style” square-cut pizza. It’s the way I remember it growing up. They don’t skimp on toppings and the sauce and crust are perfect!
… more
Haley Matuszynski
We have always enjoyed Don Gino’s for pizza – it’s close by and fairly inexpensive. It’s thin and crispy crust, which is my husbands fave, and it’s greasy without being TOO over the top.
… more
… View more