Old-fashioned counter-serve American diner & sports pub with patio seating & typical comfort food. Based on 614 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2055 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Penfield, NY 14526
Phone: (585) 377-1040
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jon Zimmerman
Recommended by a local for a good “Garbage Plate” dish (a local staple), and Don’s did not disappoint. The chili sauce was a perfect topping!
… more
LeeAnne Valentine
The food was absolutely amazing. The only thing that should be made clear is the Pub is table service only meaning their foods and service is different than the menu in front and you have to get your food. So if you’re looking to just order, grab your tray and sit, that’s the front area. If you’re looking to just sit down and let hostess bring food, that’s the Pub area. Other than that, great food, great waitress, and quiet atmosphere.
… more
Leah’K Baker
At some point it was an issue with the food on one of my orders for me and the kids on my second visit…. Yup it was Amazing the first time I had them, however it was late in the evening everyone was exhausted and they had a few call offs . The owner did track me down to apologize and he stood by his Food. From the first visit I Absolutely stand behind this local Buisness. We are not all perfect and have our faults. He was very kind and made a point to say they would do right next time. I declined the offer of a free meal because they deserve to get paid for everything they do. I was a little exhausted myself and ready to eat so I was in my feelings a little bit. However they did really well the next time and will continue to be amazing!!!! Try them out I deleted my original Post because Everyone deserves a Second chance and they passed with flying colors. Thanks again to all of the staff and manager for tracking me down that really meant the world to me.
… more
Tricia Reuter
We were just looking for a quick bite that was NOT fast food chain like, and this did the trick. Comparable to a Tom Wahls or Bill Gray’s as far as type of food, but still unique. My son got a side of their BBQ sauce for his sandwich, and that was definitely yummy and unique.
… more
Mychale Boss
One of the best things about our 2-3 trips to upstate New York every year is we get to dine at Don’s Original! I could eat there everyday. I wish they had one in dallas! Katie’s soups are off the chart delicious, and Alisha and all the other servers are super friendly and excellent at what they do! Don and Karen take great care of their restaurants and their staff and it shows! Can’t wait to see you guys again this summer! 🙂 Katie, you totally killed it with the Manhattan clam chowder this Christmas! You’re totally my favorite! 🙂
… more
Evan Bartter
Was there with an old friend we ordered drinks and dinner, the price was worth every penny the food was amazing the drinks were perfect and I mean perfect! I told the man behind the bar I wanted something sweet but strong he made me a long island iced tea legit best one I’ve had! Sweet enough to drink it with food but strong enough that I ubered home! If your looking for drinks and food the pub on the right hand side is going to be your best friend but if you want a quiet home town diner feel try the separated diner type part right out front. Whether it’s family feels you want or drinks to knock you out either way Don’s is the place to be
… more
Connie Spencer-Plante
The dining area is crowded. The person taking the order didn’t help with information about the food nor asked any questions. There were not many choices for the frozen custard.
… more
A C
I eagerly arrived here to eat dinner and was profiled as a potential criminal and asked to leave before I could enter for apparently exploring the public park in the rear of the lot. The manager was also so polite as to judge me for the car I drive during our brief conversation. It’s a shame they lost my business but I simply can’t patronize a business that can’t respect their customers. I was asked to return next Thursday by the manager but rest of our interaction only cemented the fact that I will likely never return here.
… more
J G
Horrible service. The lady taking the orders at the front was very rude for no reason. I was polite but I can see they do not care if a customer will return or not. I ordered a big plate and they forgot to add the hot sauce. The lady acted like she didn’t want to give it to me and didn’t even give me enough for my meal. Almost 20 dollars for horrible service and incorrect order. I won’t be back.
… more
Richard E. Lee
I have been a long time patron. The various menu options are always served with a welcoming smile and cordial appreciation. The place is kept spotless …what else can I say? Except THANK You.. for your years of great service to our community.
… more
… View more