Spacious, low-key pizza restaurant offering NYC & Chicago style pies alongside a full bar. Based on 803 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
300 W 4th St, Waterloo, IA 50701
Phone: (319) 883-3100
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sueann
This was one of the few places that was open. I got the Chicken Alfredo 9” New York style Pizza and it was so good. It had the amount right about of sauce, chicken, and veggies. Because I’m from New York and KNOW New York pizza, it wasn’t quite it. But it was still pretty good. & the wings were spicy!
… more
Ruth Museett
We ordered the New York style Starving Marvin pizza. It tasted ok, but….The salami still has the casing on it, which was annoying. Brought it up to the waitress, her response was, “on yeah….other people have been having the same issue”. ???????
… more
lilbit older
Our waitress was nice and informative. Most of the food was hot but greasy. So greasy. Pizza sticks to the serving tray but the cheese topping slides off the crust before the first bite. And then it was rather bland. When you compare the poor quality of food to the outrageous costs, we don’t understand how they’ve been in business for so long. The only food that was any good was the bread and pretzel sticks.
… more
Todd Willeat
Cheesy bread sticks were very cheesy. New York style pizza was good, but I’m not sure I’d call it New York style. There was no crust around the edge. It was thin with cheese and toppings all the way to the edge. And cut into squares. It looked like a St. Louis style, except it did have mozzarella instead of provel.
… more
Nicole O’Connor
Starvin Marvin pizza is really good! Decent taco pizza also (and I’m very picky about taco pizza)
… more
C Jones
We were in Iowa for a baseball tournament. We called them to see if they could accommodate a large party. And they did! Our waiter was great! He kept our drinks full. Would definitely recommend this place if you’re ever in Waterloo!!
… more
Roxanne Molskness
Worth a stop. Deep dish Chicago style for my hubby and New York Stye for me. The 7 in size was just right for one person. Sauce was yummy and good crust too. No complaints. Our server, Mason, was super friendly and welcoming. We’ll come again next time in Waterloo.
… more
Jeff Brunning
1 hour after we sat down the waitress came out and told us that they had forgotten to make our pizza. At 1 hour and 25 minutes we got our food. I love the pizza, but holy cow, isn’t there a system in place that prevents this? They only charged me ½ price, but I’m on a company card. People that weren’t even there benefited from their mistake, but not me.
… more
Angie Hickok
Waited an hour for food, two more minutes and was walking out. We were only ones there. Had to ask for refills.. twice. Cooks were eating while making food. Food was good when we finally got it.
… more
Martha Garcia-Wegener
The pizza was great and very yummy. Crust was nice and crispy. The service was good. Loved the 90s music they were playing! I would just request closed captioning put on TV’s. My kids were watching the TV with MSNBC news and were asking a lot of questions since we couldn’t hear it nor tell what they were talking about.
… more
… View more