Based on 75 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4919 Oleander Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34982
Phone: (772) 828-3057
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Yenca
Did take out. Very large slices of deliciousness. We order extra basil on the White Pizza Special (ricotta, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, tomatoes and spinach.) Also ordered the Hawaiian (ham, pineapple, mozzarella, and bacon.) Reasonable priced. Let’s support small business.
… more
Jeffery Clanton (Jeff)
This place has GREAT food! Ordering online is super easy, and the estimated time for pickup has always been accurate (haven’t ordered delivery). It has outdoor tables, but during the day it’s pretty hot. The inside is nice with huge New York City graphics, which is cool. It’s become a regular for me.
… more
Bandit99
First time here and it was really good in my opinion. I would definitely come back here and bring other ppl as well. I really like the garlic rolls. The garlic butter was really good. Some places just chop up garlic and put in oil. We also had some hot wings. Interesting flavor or to much seasoning nonetheless I enjoyed them too.
… more
Maureen Lee
Had delivery on Saturday night, have ordered many times before, I wanted to get something different, the Margarita pizza is is absolutely delicious. It was nice to have a change from pizza sauce the mozzarella, parmesan, fresh tomatoes, basil and garlic were fantastic it’s great hot or cold. I’ve never gotten a bad meal from this location this by far is the best. The people that take the orders are friendly, the delivery people are great. If you haven’t tried the food from this location you really need to. Have not been in the store so I can’t comment on the atmosphere.
… more
O.G. R/H
This is some great pizza! Don’t let the size or location fool you, there are times when we feel the toppings could be a bit more generous but when we eat the pizza we are just happy to have a place that uses quality ingredients and cooks it just right. I would’ve given a full 5 stars for service, but it is agitating when on the phone and being asked, “is that it?” after each item. We’re stopping to do that, rather than just continuing on with the order. It sends a message, of hurry up, while ironically wasting time. I’ll continue with the order and I promise I’ve got better things to do than silently holding the phone to my ear too… “can I get you anything else”, would be a bit more polite”, but “ok” says you got it recorded and I can move on with the order. I promise you I’ll tell you “that’s all” when I’m finished.
… more
Rebecca Zelanin
Good pizza, but I’ve had better. It’s close to my home, so that’s a plus. The toppings were generous, but we ordered which didn’t come while we waited for the pizza. Yes, when we asked, they gave it to us, but by then we wanted the hot pizza and we took it home. It might be a 5 star fir me if the sauce had more flavor.
… more
E M
Coming from NY I was hoping to find a pizzeria that wouldn’t disappoint and Downtown Bennys is the SPOT! I’ve been to a few different pizzerias in the area that are overall good but I’m so happy that I found this gem. The pizza is so delicious and the calzones are AMAZING. My kids are super picky and they 100% approve of everything, there favorite being the garlic knots. Im looking forward to trying the rest of the menu as I’m sure everything will taste amazing. Totally worth the drive if you’re a little farther out, you wont be disappointed.
… more
snifferdogg forfreedom
Alsome place great service excellent food . My kid loves this play . Big slices of pizza and there Philly cheese steak sub is great tasting. 5 stars baby.
… more
Kmillz1484
Paul and crew are exceptional when it comes to good pizza.. Last night I ordered a chicken parmigiana pizza and it was phenomenal.. The counter man is polite and professional, along with the rest of the staff.. They work hard and deserved to be tipped.. Can’t say enough good things about my experiences with Downtown Bennys!!
… more
Joelle Fritz
2nd time here.. first time delivery was 1hr 20min but food was hot and good and just figured busy night. Today picked up same dinner, order was wrong, called and girl answering phone was rude, offered to deliver new dinners, they did on time 45 minutes later and missing items. When we called back upset she tried to say she was manager. None the less actual manager got on phone and said he’d send rest of dinner. We opted out of waiting for remainder of dinner but think this will be our last time unless we are eating in. Each of our orders have been almost $60
… more
… View more