Based on 229 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
103 Milan Ave, Amherst, OH 44001
Phone: (440) 985-9866
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Steven Dummitt
We visited here with some family, and they have a lot of options from subs to specialty pizzas and more. We tried a variety of things, including a BLT sub, Pepperoni bombs, Flaming Kramer pizza, and Blazing Buffalo Mac n Cheese pizza.
… more
Jordan S.
Very nice open sports themed dining room! Got the ten topping deluxe well-done and Mac n cheese pizza…. ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL! Have gotten the pepperoni bombs before, great appetizer. Pizza sauce for dipping is awesome, if you like spicy then grab some spicy garlic Parm sauce to drizzle over your pizza. Staff are very friendly, very clean inside, online ordering process is easy as well. Contender for top pizza in Amherst
… more
Xyane Alexander
D’Tutanelli’s had purchased Granny D’s pizza in Lorain, then they moved to Amherst. They had kept the pizza, etc mostly the way Granny D’s made it. Which was fantastic. We were there recently, and found that someone else had purchased it. Although we were told that they were still using the same recipes, they definitely were not. The pizza doesn’t taste anything like Granny D’s. The last owners had changed it a little bit, but it’s completely different now. If you go there because you’re a fan of Granny D’s, you’re going to be very disappointed. I will say the service was great. Really improved. The two people we talked to working there, we’re extremely friendly and attentive. I just wish the food hadn’t changed. Probably won’t go back very often, if at all.
… more
Kyle
$69 for two pizzas, wings, and some cheesy bread. They charge you an extra couple dollars for crispy wings, and they tact on a mandatory 15% on online orders. Yes, my wife had to tip the restaurant 15% for me to go pickup for a carry out order. Will never dine here again. Could’ve gone to Lorenzo’s for that money, and their pizza is actually good.
… more
Steve Morrell
Unfortunately this is the second and last time I will be ordering from here. Although the service was fast and friendly, the product was not good, made incorrectly and overpriced. I ordered a medium cheese, pepperoni and mushroom pizza and 6 garlic parmesan wings well done. First off I was charged $2.25 for mushrooms and there was not a single mushroom on the pizza. Also a $13.50 medium pizza with an additional charge of $2.25 for pepperoni seems a bit steep to me. The wings I ordered were $10.99 for 6 which is outrageous and they were awful. There was no parmesan on them and they were soggy. I ordered them well done so I expected them crisper. So at the end of the day it cost $28 for a medium pizza and 6 wings, I was charged for ingredients that were never added to the pizza and the wings were missing parmesan and soggy. Terrible take out experience.
… more
Ashley Drummond
My family has dined in their newly reopened dining room twice and each time we were promptly greeted by very friend staff and their food is so good! For this month they have a special for a $10.99 medium 1 topping pizza when dining in, we ordered pepperoni very good also we love the cheese bombs and twist ums! Thanks for great food and great service!
… more
Joisey Mc (Joisey)
Really, really good pizza, salads and appetizers
… more
April Tomecko
Always a great experience getting dinner, never had a bad pizza. Highly recommend!!
… more
Laurie Crano
Under cooked calzone. Chewy wings. This is our second time trying this place after new ownership? Pretty darn gross and expensive. Save your money.
… more
Holly Vann
Delicious pizza, reasonable prices and super friendly staff.
… more
… View more