El Pitallito Menu – New York, NY

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : New York, NY

Homestyle Mexican fare, including tacos & tamales, offered up in simple, compact quarters. Based on 174 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

El Pitallito 10032

Address:
3854 Broadway, New York, NY 10032

Phone: (212) 568-6878

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 10 AM–10 PM
Thursday 10 AM–10 PM
Friday 10 AM–10 PM
Saturday 10 AM–10 PM
Sunday 10 AM–10 PM
Monday 10 AM–10 PM
Tuesday 10 AM–10 PM

Menu

Aperitivos
Guacamole
Mashed avocados with chips.
$12.00
Pico De Gallo
Served with nachos.
$10.00
Nachos Con Carne
Preparados con la carne de su gusta, frijoles, crema, pico de gallo, guacamole y quesillo. Crispy chips with beans, cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, pico de gallo and your choice of meat.
$15.00
Nachos Con Camaron (Shrimp) $17.00
Nachos Con Lengua (Beef Tongue) $17.00
Plain Nachos $12.00
Desayunos Mexicanos
Huevos Rancheros
Dos huevos fritos con salsa Verde. Corn tortillas smothered with red sauce, topped with fried eggs with cilantro, fresh cheese and cream.
$11.00
Huevos A La Mexicana
Huevos revueltos con jalapenos, cebolla y tomates. Scrambled eggs with jalapenos, onions and tomatoes.
$11.00
Huevos Con Chorizo
Huevos revueltos con chorizo Mexicano picado. Scrambled eggs mixed with Mexican chorizo.
$11.00
Huevos Con Jamon
Huevos al gusto con jamon en slices. Eggs any style with ham.
$11.00
Huevos Con Nopales
Eggs with cactus.
$11.00
Huevos Con Salchicha
Eggs with sausage.
$11.00
Chilaquiles Verdes O Rojos
Crispy tortillas cooked in green or red sauce. Topped with sour cream, cheese powder and onions. Served with beans
$13.00
Ensaladas
Ensalada
Lechuga, tomates, cebollas y pepino.
$7.00
Ensalada De Aguacate
Avocado salad.
$9.00
Ensalada Con Pollo Asado
Avocado salad with grilled chicken.
$12.00
Ensalada Con Camarones
Avocado salad with shrimp.
$17.00
Sopas
Caldo Rojo Res
Red beef soup with vegetables.
$14.00
Caldo Rojo De Pollo
Red chicken soup with vegetables.
$14.00
Pancita De Res
Spicy beef tripe soup.
$14.00
Pozole
Hominy corn soup with chicken or pork.
$14.00
Sopa De Pollo Con Vegetales
Mix vegetables with chicken.
$14.00
Sopa De Mariscos
Mix seafood soup.
$17.00
Sopa De Camaron Con Picante Y Vegetales $16.00
Birria
Birria stew. Served with tortillas, onions and lemon
$14.00
Tacos
Tacos (3pcs)
On a corn tortilla topped with lettuce, tomato, sour cream, onions and cilantro. Choice of meat.
$12.00
Taco Mixtos (3pcs)
On a corn tortilla topped with lettuce, tomato, sour cream, onions and cilantro. Choice of 3 meats.
$15.00
Camaron (Shrimp) Taco (3pcs)
Lechuga, tomato, cebolla, cilantro and crema.
$14.00
Cecina (Salted Beef) Taco (3pcs)
Lechuga, tomato, cebolla, cilantro and crema.
$12.00
Birria (Beef Stew) Taco (3pcs)
Lechuga, tomato, cebolla, cilantro and crema.
$16.00
Lengua (Cow Tongue) Taco (3pcs)
Lechuga, tomato, cebolla, cilantro and crema.
$15.00
Oreja Tacos
Lechuga, tomato, cebolla, cilantro and crema.
$15.00
Queso (Cheese) Tacos Dorados (3pcs)
Rolled hard corn tortillas with your choice of cheese, chicken or potato. sour cream, cheese and lettuce. Served with rice and beans.
$12.00
Pollo (Chicken) Tacos Dorados (5pcs)
Rolled hard corn tortillas with your choice of cheese, chicken or potato. sour cream, cheese and lettuce. Served with rice and beans.
$12.00
Papa (Potato) Taco Dorados (5pcs)
Rolled hard corn tortillas with your choice of cheese, chicken or potato. sour cream, cheese and lettuce. Served with rice and beans.
$12.00
Tacos Dorados Mixtos (5pcs)
Rolled hard corn tortillas.
$13.00
Pescado(Fish) Taco (3pcs) $14.00
Burritos
Burrito De Camaron (Shrimp) $14.00
Lengua (Beef Tongue) Burrito $15.00
Barbacoa (Goat) Burrito $15.00
Burritos Mixtos
Choose 2 meats.
$16.00
Burrito Pollo(Chicken) $12.00
Burrito Bistec(Beef) $12.00
Burrito Cecina(Salty Beef) $12.00
Burrito Alpastor(Roast Pork) $12.00
Burrito Carne Enchilada(Spicy Pork) $12.00
Burrito Chorizo(Sausage) $12.00
Burrito Carnitas(Pork) $12.00
Burrito Birria $14.00
Burrito Hongos(Mushroom) $12.00
Enchiladas
Bistec(Beef)Enchilada $15.00
Cecina (Salted Beef) Enchilada $15.00
Al Pastor (Roast Pork) Enchilada $15.00
Chorizo (Spicy Mexican Sausage) Enchilada $15.00
Queso Fresco (Fresh Cheese) Enchilada $15.00
Pollo(Chicken) Enchilada $15.00
Carne Enchilada(Spicy Roast Pork) $15.00
Carnitas(Pork) Enchilada $15.00
Sopes
Bistec (Beef) Sope (3pcs) $13.00
Pollo (Chicken) Sope (3pcs)
Beef tongue.
$13.00
Cecina (Salty Beef) Sope (3pcs)
Shrimp.
$13.00
Chorizo (Sausage) Sope (3pcs) $13.00
Al Pastor (Roast Pork) Sope (3pcs) $13.00
Tinga (Spicy Chicken) Sope (3pcs) $13.00
Hongos (Mushroom) Sope (3pcs) $13.00
Lengua (Cow Tongue) Sope (3pcs) $15.00
Camaron (Shrimp) Sope (3pcs) $13.00
Birria Sopes $15.00
Sopes Queso(Cheese) $13.00
Barbacoa(Goat) Sopes $13.00
Quesadillas
Quesadilla (3pcs) $13.00
Papa (Potato) Quesadilla (3pcs) $13.00
Lengua (Beef Tongue) Quesadilla (3pcs) $15.00
Barbacoa (Goat) Quesadilla (3pcs) $14.00
Camaron (Shrimp) Quesadilla (3pcs) $13.00
Birria Quesadillas $15.00
Queso(Cheese) Quesadilllas $13.00
Huarache
Huarache $9.00
Huarache Cecina (Salted Beef) $12.00
Huarache Camaron (Shrimp) $14.00
Huarache Lenga (Cow Tongue) $14.00
Huarache Birria (Beef Stew) $13.00
Huarache Tinga(Spicy Chicken) $9.00
Huarache Carne Enchilada(Spicy Roast Pork) $9.00
Huarache Carnitas(Pork) $9.00
Gorditas
Pollo (Chicken) Gorditas (3pcs) $14.00
Bistec (Beef) Gorditas (3pcs) $14.00
Carnitas (Roast Pork) Gorditas (3pcs) $14.00
Cecina (Salted Beef) Gorditas (3pcs) $14.00
Al Pastor (Spicy Pork) Gorditas (3pcs) $14.00
Fajitas
Fajita $16.00
Camaron (Shrimp) Fajita $18.00
Lengua (Beef Tongue) Fajita $18.00
Alambres
Alambre $18.00
Camaron (Shrimp) Alambre $18.00
Lengua (Beef Tongue) Alambre $20.00
Platillos
Bistec Ranchero
Nopales, cebolla, rafas y tomates. Grilled steak with peppers and tomatoes.
$16.00
Chuleta Ranchera
Grilled pork chop with cactus, onions, spicy peppers, cilantro. Served with rice and beans and corn tortillas.
$16.00
Pechuga Ranchera
Grilled chicken breast with cactus, onions, spicy peppers, cilantro. Served with rice beans and tortillas.
$16.00
Cecina Encebollada
Salty beef with grilled onions. Served with rice, beans and corn tortillas
$16.00
Cecina Ranchera
Grilled salty beef with cactus, onions, spicy peppers and cilantro. Served with rice beans and corn tortilla.
$16.00
Bistec A La Mexicana
Bistec con tomate, cebolla y jalapenos. Steak sauteed with onions, peppers and jalapenos.
$16.00
Milanesa De Pollo
Breaded chicken breast with salad, rice, beans and corn tortillas.
$16.00
Milanesa De Res
Breaded beef with salad, rice and beans, and corn tortillas.
$16.00
Mole Poblano
Pollo con salsa tipica de mole. Chicken topped with mole sauce.
$15.00
Chiles Rellenos
Jalapenos rellenos de queso. Stuffed peppers with cheese.
$15.00
Costillas En Salsa Verde
Ribs topped with green salsa.
$13.00
Tortitas De Queso Y Salsa
Cheese patty with cheese sauce.
$13.00
Pipian De Pollo
Pollo chicken with pipian sauce.
$13.00
Pollo En Salsa Roja
Chicken stew in red sauce.
$13.00
Adobo De Puerco
Pork in adobo sauce.
$13.00
Chicharron En Salsa Verde
Skin pork in green sauce.
$13.00
Barbacoa
Goat.
$16.00
Huaximole (Puerco O Pollo) $13.00
Mariscos
Filete De Pescado Empanizado
Breaded fish fillet.
$16.00
Mojarra Frita
Fried porgie served with rice, beans, salad, and corn tortillas.
$18.00
Camarones A La Mexicana $18.00
Camarones A La Diabla $18.00
Camarones Asados $18.00
Coctel De Camarones
Shrimp cocktail.
$16.00
Aguas Frescas
Jamaica $3.50
Horchata $3.50
Tamarindo $3.50
Pina $3.50
Lemonade $3.50
Melon $3.50
Papaya $3.50
Jugo De Naranja $5.00
Jugo De Zanahoria $5.00
Mixto $6.00
Batidas $5.00
Tostadas
Pollo (Chicken) Tostadas (3pcs) $12.00
Bistec Carnitas Toastada (3pcs) $12.00
Cecina (Salted Beef) Enchilada (3pcs) $12.00
Al Pastor (Spicy Pork) Tostada (3pcs) $12.00
Camaron (Shrimp) Tostada (3pcs) $13.00
Mixtos Tostada (3pcs) $13.00
Cemitas
Milanesa De Res (Breaded Beef) Cemita $9.00
Milanesa Pollo (Breaded Chicken) Cemita $9.00
Carnitas (Fried Pork) Cemita $9.00
Salchicha Con Huevo (Eggs And Sausage) Cemita $9.00
Jamon (Ham) Cemita $9.00
Bistec (Beef) Cemita $9.00
Pechuga Asada (Grilled Chicken) Cemita $9.00
Quesillo (Cheese) Cemita $9.00
Cecina (Salty Beef) Cemita $9.00
Chorizo (Spicy Sausage) Cemita $9.00
Tortas
Milanesa De Res (Breaded Beef) Torta $8.00
Milanesa Pollo (Breaded Chicken) Torta $8.00
Carnitas (Fried Pork) Torta $8.00
Salchicha Con Huevo (Sausage And Eggs) Torta $8.00
Jamon (Ham) Torta $8.00
Bistec (Beef) Torta $8.00
Pechuga Asada (Gilled Chicken) Torta $8.00
Quesillo (Cheese) Torta $8.00
Cecina (Salty Beef) Torta $8.00
Chorizo (Spicy Sausage) Torta $8.00
Torta Cubana
Refried beans, Oaxaca cheese, ham, egg, avocado, onions, jalapenos and mayonnaise.
$8.50
Kid’s Menu
Kids Chicken Nuggets And Fries $8.00
Kids Cheeseburger And Fries $8.00
Side Orders
Arroz And Frijoles
Rice and beans.
$5.00
Nopales Asados
Grilled cactus.
$5.00
Cambray Asado
Grilled onions.
$5.00
Tortillas (3pcs)
Corn tortilla.
$2.00
Papas Fritas
French fries.
$5.00
Aguacate $5.00
Red Sauce $3.00
Green Sauce $3.00
Beverages
Champurrado $1.50
Arroz Con Leche $1.50
Soda (20oz) $2.00
Soda (12oz Can) $1.50
Jarritos $2.00
Soda (2 Litres) $4.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jennifer Flores
Great family owned restaurant! Authentic Mexican food. My family and I enjoyed our food! Definitely worth checking out!

… more

Sanil Cuello
I ordered 1 taco birria and 1 quesadilla birria. What I received was 2 orders of tacos with meat . I called back to inform them that the order is wrong. On Grubhub, it says that the Quesadilla Birria comes with Cheese, onions, rice and salad, none of the orders had cheese or onions and only one order had the tortillas cooked in the Birria sauce but was completely burned, none of them were made how it states in the menu. What made it even more frustrating is that I explained this to the lady and she kept insisting that quesadillas doesn’t come with anything that was stated in THEIR menu and none of the tacos comes with cheese unless asked for, for an additional cost. Additionally, the tortillas were burnt and the meat had a strange after taste. It is so disappointing since I spent $30 dollars and they refused to acknowledge my complaint.

… more

Yesenia G
Not sure how authentic I consider this restaurant but the food was delicious! The portions were large as well. The waitress was attentive and really nice.

… more

O V H
Authentic Mexican food in the Heights.

… more

Colin Chauche
Fantastic Mexican place. Probably the best plate of nachos I’ve ever had! All the portions are generous and at a fair price. Will be coming back for sure!

… more

Artem Levin
Their delivery guy tried to scam me out of 5 dollars, gave him $62, counted 3 times prior, gave it to him, he left, returned 3 mins later, said it was only $57. Called the place, the person I spoke to right away told me he doubts that this is what happened. Just be careful with them.

… more

Kenny Thegreat
The food is trash. It’s very bland and tortilla itself is low quality and taste like flour. Overall do not go here the food is a zero out of ten. If I could give it 0 stars I would!

… more

Michael De Paepe
Not even one star because the waitress charged me 22 % tax on the bill. She said it 18 % tax and I was in a hurry so I didn’t take the time to figure it out. Tax should be just under 9% right? the food was good in spite of the apparent tourist rip-off. I am sorry I left a tip.

… more

Bhuwan G
Originally I m not from Mexico but I love mexican food. I always eat Mexican food. First time I tried a kind odlf food in this resrltaurent, Oh my god, I feel really bad.They provide not nice food

… more

J.C Solis
In my part i am very very very disapointed!!! Food was terrible, we ordered chicken milanesa torta it was disgusting, chicken was very dry and tasted old. Also we ordered one of the specials of the day and the pork was very dry and it also tasted very old. None of the dishes were good or fresh. Luckily the only thing that was edible was a burrito we ordered for my kid everything else was dry and old and not fresh at all. Also when we sended the food back the waitress had a nasty attitude and, they wanted us to pay for disgusting food, i think if you went out to eat it is to enjoy the food or at least it has to be edible. Really bad experience. We wont ever come back. These people really need to rethink and analyze what they’re serving people and do something positive about it.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions