El Potro Mexican Restaurant Nineveh, in Nineveh, IN, is the leading Mexican restaurant serving Johnson, Morgan and Brown counties since 2018. We offer tacos, enchiladas, burritos, quesadillas, foreign and domestic beers, margaritas, carryout service and much more. For your next meal, visit El Potro Mexican Restaurant Nineveh.
Based on 284 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
8002 S Nineveh Rd, Nineveh, IN 46164
Phone: (317) 933-6262
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kevin B
Great mexican food in a small town out of the way strip mall. The menu is large and suited to just about any mexican dish you can imagine. Staff is happy to adjust items on the menu for you as well. Drinks were awesome. I had enchiladas that were out of this world good and thierbcrispy beef taco was loaded with meat. Will go again when I the area.
… more
shama malik
I just went there 2/8/2023 before I walked in of course it looked sketchy I was afraid to go in I went in anyways I’m complaining because I got food poisoning sure it looked delicious but when I ate it the next morning came past I had diareah. Nausea severe cramps and I threw up twice and I’m still having cramps and this is my first food poisoning Maybe everyone else has a different experience but I wouldn’t recommend it food poisoning should never happen never not one time not two times none
… more
Amy Berti
We had the chicken fajitas. It was so big my husband and I split it. It was absolutely delicious. Down to the chips and salsa. And queso. It was so so good. 8 ordered the mango margarita on the rocks. With top shelf tequila which was Patron. My husband got the regular house margarita. It was lime-ey.. the food and atmosphere was so great. I wish this place was closer to home. Because this would be one of our regular spots. I locked my keys in car. These gentlemen here were so so nice they were so quick to help us. I mean to stop what they were doing to help us was just incredible. I wish I lived out here. Everyone is kind. And so willing to help out when they see someone in need. I think 3-4 people that left the restaurant asked Javier if he needed help. I mean I live in Southport and not many people would ask that if they seen us trying to get into car.
… more
Jason Jones
Great restaurant, amazing service I couldn’t finish the burrito but food was delicious. I will always go to this restaurant.
… more
Karen Nolan
Very nice ambiance. The food is excellent. I go there often and always get great service. The prices are also excellent. They offer a really nice selection of drinks as well.
… more
Tracey Callahan
We love el Potro. We’re so lucky to have them in the community. The food is fantastic. Drinks are festive. Staff is top notch. Never had a bad experience in eight years.
… more
Christy Thomas
Fast and friendly service!! The restaurant it self is nice inside, i love the round lights that are above the table’s! Reasonable price’s on their food and not to mention the food is delicious!! Their frozen margarita’s are the bomb!! Great place for family to go and have a dinner night!!
… more
Cody Marshall
Always easy to get in and out of during lunch time and with the chips and salsa and meal it is very affordable! Paired with great taste… hard to pass up!
… more
Jose Garcia
Pros: Authentic Mexican great tasting food; excellent Horchata; Excellent Salsa!!!!! Great staff!!!
… more
Mark Kinder
I have eaten here with friends 3 separate times and it has always been a great meal, service and atmosphere. Highly recommend
… more
… View more