Based on 513 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
100 S Stuart Ave, Elkton, VA 22827
Phone: (540) 298-1001
Website: http://elktongoodfellaspizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Audrine Mascarenhas
Highly recommend this restaurant for Italian fast food. Our waitress was amazing. She pretty much served all other tables but was very patient and helpful. We food is very tasty too. We ordered a small Stromboli which was sufficient to feed 2 people and a cheese pizza slice which was simple but tasty. Pretty casual vibe. Our vegetarian friends ordered zita and loved it as well.
… more
George Snyder
Our waitress was the best ever. Hustled constantly running all around and did a excellent job. The food was perfect and delicious. Highly recommend for others to enjoy the food and great service.
… more
Michael Connolly
We got a 10% off card from Massenutten. Thought it was for one big restaurant on 33. Turns out it’s for a small place in the town of Elkton. We won out. We will be going back when we return for another vacation.
… more
Daniel Anderson
This is the first time I have ever eaten at this restaurant but I say it has very good delicious food and a very good customer service and affordable prices that I would highly suggest going to it if I were you and I do plan on going to this restaurant the next time I’m in the town of Elkton Virginia.
… more
Amanda Richards
Everything was excellent. Very friendly. Portion sizes were huge. Always had another drink waiting. The only issues was the women’s bathroom door didn’t lock.
… more
Chuck Roy
Good service and well maintained, small restaurant. The food is very good but not the best in the area. The steak and cheese and pizza we’re great, but the fries were pretty tasteless. Update: The service, atmosphere, and food were all great. The fries are still the only item that could use more flavor.
… more
Mr. Peej B
Love this little place! We were on our way back from Luray and saw Goodfellas. We had to stop and check it out. The food was great, priced well and fast. Our waitress made us feel like home and we will definitely be back when we pass through.
… more
Lin Brann
Decent place to get pizza, subs, sandwiches, or pasta without breaking the bank. Inside is not fancy, service was hometown friendly and quick. Expect 20 – 30 minutes wait during lunch hours. The owner has closed two out of six tables in the restaurant to keep dine in customers at a safe distance. Fork and knife are individually stored in a disposable bag. We have ordered three slices of pizza, meatballs parmigiana, and steak & cheese special. Pizzas were very good, definitely worth of five stars, however both subs were nothing special. I have mix feelings about this place, you will have to try and be the judge.
… more
Steve Goad
Great place to eat with an equally great staff. Good selection at fair prices. Definitely will be coming back again.
… more
Bobby Miller
Man, this place is good!!! I really like their cheesesteak and even the fries were delicious. Very affordable too! It’s not a “nice” restaurant or anything, but a good “hole in the wall” to enjoy a simple, fantastic meal!
… more
… View more