Unassuming cash-only pizza joint offers NYC-style pies in a tiny space, with time slots for pickup. Based on 115 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2995 Shattuck Ave., Berkeley, CA 94705
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Friday | 5–9 PM |
| Saturday | 5–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
N N
This place is an absolute gem!! Our friend recommended us this place and we finally got around to try it. Make sure if you want to try this place that you order online early! Otherwise you will have to wait a bit to pick up your pizza. We got the Gina Calabrese and it was so delicious. It’s NY style pizza and it looks like there is only one person making all the pizzas so feels very homemade but super tasty! Will be back to try other pizzas.
… more
Aeen Asghar
Officially our favorite pizza in Berkeley! One man show. Need to order early starting at 9AM. Each order gets a specific pick up time.
… more
Andrew Jing
One of my favorite pies in the bay area. It’s kind of a blend of NY style and neopolitan, with great toppings. Zero frills. Not the easiest to order, but worth it every time for me. I’ve had the best of NY pizzas, and in terms of quality, this is right up there for me.
… more
Elliott Armstrong
Keith is legit. A lot of pies this size are overtopped and have too much sauce and cheese. Not here. His balance is perfect. His sauce is sweet, and that’s not to my personal taste but it was still delicious. The dough is the star here. Complex, tangy and subtle hints of sour. Outstanding work. I hope he gets to a point where he can get staff and more space. We need more great pizzaiolos in the bay! I say that as one myself! Great job Keith!
… more
Albert Aydin
Absolutely incredible pizza. I recently moved here from New Jersey and was told I’d never find NJ/NY pizza but boy were they wrong. The biggest thing to keep in mind is to check their website and call at 4pm to put in your order, it’s easy. And they give you an estimated time of when your pizza will be ready (either dine in or take out) and he was spot on with that time. The crust, sauce, cheese, visual, aromas, everything was exactly what I want in a pizza. And btw cash only!
… more
Candace T
I generally shun pizza, except for my husband’s or mother-in-law’s, which are white and Roman-style. The former ordering system was a hurdle, but we finally tried it tonight. The crust is crisp and flavorful, and somehow fresh and light. It’s got char but it doesn’t taste of ash. The toppings don’t make the dough soggy and it thankfully doesn’t reek of garlic or dried oregano. Thank you!
… more
Gautam Jain
The crust was perfection. It’s lighter and thinner than most thin crusts I’ve had and I much prefer this. Had the right amount of crispness and chew.
… more
Nick Calcaterra
Emilia’s suffers from one of the greatest fallacies in pizza along with a desperate hype-train in a quality-pizza-barren region. All the hallmarks of a social media-lauded Neapolitan style are present:
… more
Christina Wilson
It’s absolutely delicious pizza- no frills, no gimmicks no putting up with bs. Order ahead!
… more
Trey Singleton
My favorite Pizza in the world! If your in the bay area and love Pizza you must eat Keith’s pizza. Start calling at 4 to get your time slot and be on time. It’s not hard folks! Thanks Keith!!! Until next time
… more
… View more