Based on 10 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
4 Hamburg Ave, Wantage, NJ 07461
Phone: (973) 868-2268
Social Profile: 
Reviews
robert gebhardt
My mother was born in Naples Italy. It was her 70th bday. Wanted something fun and different. Reached out to these guys about 3 weeks prior (yea, a little behind the eight ball). My request, only a sat in the middle of the summer mid day, with only 3 weeks notice (wasn’t expecting a yes) Their answer, “of course we can make that happen” After working a morning at the Sparta Farmers market they came over and set up and amazing experience for me and my “fresh off the boat” Italian family. It was amazing. The pizza is amazing, but what makes it better is Emily and her people. It truly felt like a we had all known each other forever. If you are looking for great food, fresh and innovative recipes and just some really nice people taking care of everything for you. These guys are your answer.
… more
Kate Assaraf
I don’t even like pizza but this is the one exception. Every single pie we have ever eaten from Emily’s hearth has been so delicious…will always order from here, even if I’m not hungry. It’s truly that good
… more
Aj capella
Emilly and grace are so awesome. We met them at the sparta market. The pizza was phenomenal very authentic local product. 10/10 highly recommend
… more
Joanne Davies
We got pizza and bread from here during Applefest. Tender delicious dough that doesn’t need a mountain of heavy cheese to compensate. Lovely air bubbles and charring. The bread has remained delicious for 3 days too! It’s so filling and satisfying. How bread and pizza should be. Yum.
… more
Mike McD
Bit of a scam. Very busy for them but they changed our order even after we re-discussed it. Then sold us 2 corn white pies instead of margarita and peach pies. Definitely leaning on “locally sourced” to overcharge.
… more
Damien Georges
Just had two of the best pizzas we have ever had. Perfectly cooked, amazing dough. Is not cheap but nothing is.
… more
JTJ
Seemed like nice people, but $22 for a mini margarita pizza. 30 minute wait. Not a craft pie. Need to reevaluate value proposition
… more
Michael Mead
I rarely write a negative review. But this time, well, take a look at the pics. Burnt bad. Bitter burnt taste. Almost no cheese or Sauce. $26.
… more
Rebecca Lerner
Amazing fresh made pizza! We ate it all in one minute. Cant wait to get more!
… more
AD L
Fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that change with the seasons, I love Emily’s Hearth – she knows her bread and pizza!
… more
… View more