Detroit-style square pizzas, Italian sandwiches & a signature burger in a brick-clad setting. Based on 510 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
83 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003
Phone: (917) 463-3737
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Deniz Gün
Great pizza! Crusty on the outside and pretty chewy on the inside in a good way! You can pick the pizza (we had the MVP which was great) and add on any toppings you want. One pizza has 6 square slices and it’s enough for two. We also had the simple greens salad which was really nice. Highly recommend.
… more
fabian doris
A simply amazing experience from the service to the food. I got the Big Mozz Sticks and a Margherita pizza. Both were delicious. The standout was definitely the Le Big Matt Burger with waffle fries. I would highly recommend it to anyone who’s visiting.
… more
Ana Karina Sepulveda Jerez
Was invited a couple of months ago to the other Emmys at Hells Kitchen, this experience was just as fabulous and delicious as the first time. They have seasonal menus, which means there are always new plates and drinks to try! Exceptional service from the Laura, which is the second time she serves me, the restaurant is very well organized, lighted and welcoming, very comfy, would totally recommend to my friends and family and would definitely be back soon! LOVEDDDDD ITTT <3
… more
Akua G. Asare MD
I spent time with my sister during my quick trip up to #NYC. She took me to here, where we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves on meatballs, cheesy garlic bread, and two of the three pizzas we ordered. We could only eat a couple of pieces of each pizza, but we gave it a good try. The colony and Miranda were solid, but the deluxe lagged far behind. There’s just something about that hot honey that sets them OFF! I wish they had pepper flakes, though
… more
Daniel O’Sullivan
Great place for pizza with my two sons on a hot Sunday afternoon. The waitress was lovely and perfectly attentive. The pizza was excellent and their gluten free pizza was the best we’ve tasted. We will definitely be back.
… more
Alexander Kontoleon
If you are looking for a change from NY pizza, this is where you should come to get it. Detroit style pizza is more fluffy deep dish style and is done right here. The food is good, the pizza topping combinations are great. If you order an appetizer, the portion sizes are good, I recommend 1 pie per two people. The Colony remain a classic standard hold over from the original Emily in Brooklyn. The Le Big Matt is a good burger for sure, but honestly it’s hard to top the original Emmy burger. The Banana Pudding dessert feeds like 4 so save some room. Definitely worth a stop here if you havent yet if you’re a pizza lover.
… more
Bhakti Dalvi
It is a great place. Ordered the waffle fries and MVP pizza. The fries were nice and the pizza tastes good, it had big soft crust with fresh mozzarella. Also ordered the frozen pomegranate margherita and sangria. Both the drinks were strong, good and not loaded with too much ice.
… more
John A
The burger was more expensive than I would normally pay, but it was delicious and the waffle fries were perfect. I don’t usually like deep dish, but my party ordered one and its was pretty good too, didn’t have much truffle flavor.
… more
S Sab
Pizza was decent but service horrifically bad. Only writing this review in the hopes that mgmt sees it and they won’t continue to have a business if my most recent visit is an indication of how it is normally. I was one of 2 people at bar. Take a very long time to get a menu, then get the order taken, then have plates cleared, long time for the check after requesting it. Bartender would disappear frequently for lengthy periods. Seems like since Covid the wait/service industry has forgotten the Cardinal rule of make eye contact, check in. Other person at the bar who was a random stranger was clearly frustrated and commented to me how bad she thought the service was. Won’t be back anytime soon. Too many places in nyc to return after having to us experience. Again not to whine or complain but you’re not going to have a business if you can’t fix the service
… more
Vanessa Paez
Finally got to try the famous burger at Emmy Squared.
… more
… View more