Based on 100 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
Address:
22080 US-6, Keystone, CO 80435
Phone: (970) 468-9501
Website: http://extremepizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Glen Bowling
Pizza is really good but don’t expect to eat in the restaurant unless u are friends of the staff. Went there twice while we stayed in a condo here and both times it was take out only. At least 5-8 kids in there playing pool and hanging with staff. This was at 730pm on Saturday night. Went back a few days later and had great service and their pizza is very very good. We will be back.
… more
Trevor Trepanier
Great pizza, all of the ingredients were fresh and of quality. Beer selection is ok wish they had more on draft, but their bottle selection is full of verity. All of the staff were super friendly. Prices are great for summit county standards. With their location less than a mile away from me I can take a nice senic walk down the river path and get some great food and drinks. If you are looking for a great place for lunch or just need a spot to chill for a couple hours stop here and you wont be disappointed.
… more
Autumn Banks
BEWARE if you have any food sensitivities. I have Celiac and was very excited to try something from their large gluten free selection. The pickup order took over an hour, was cold, and very small in portion. I didn’t mind, as I was elated at having found decent pizza I could actually eat and commented on how “it doesn’t taste gluten-based!” I WAS MISTAKEN. Within hours I was experiencing one of the worst flares I have ever dealt with and realized my pizza was either NOT gluten free, or had been contaminated with gluten somewhere along the preparation process. Long story short, the pizza was delicious, but definitely not worth feeling like death.
… more
UtMtBiker
The Pizza is pretty good, but this place is horribly managed. I was hear in the “off season” but they need more staffing than a single server and single cook. There was a steady line of customers waiting at the door then leaving because they were never seated. The single server was trying his best and doing a pretty good job, but you can only do so much.
… more
Seren Umbenhower
The service I received was spectacular! The entire staff treated me very well. The pizza and wings are delicious and the beer options were everything I hoped for and more. Definitely a go to! I’d call this a hidden treasure in the heart of Keystone. I recommend them even
… more
Beth Ewaskowitz
We thought it would be a nice quick place to get pizza, but they never noticed us or the people in front of us standing at the hostess stand… then it took 20 minutes to get our salad, and 20 mins later they said our pizza was ready to go IN to the oven. And when it came, it was the wrong toppings. They did adjust the check, which was nice, but I don’t understand why everything was so slow, poor, and wrong…. they weren’t even all that busy…
… more
Chelsea Bichekas
Mike, the bartender was awesome! Super friendly and made me a great hot cider cocktail. Nathan was our server, he was very friendly too. Food was really good & we liked the atmosphere. Would definitely go back!
… more
Katy Scruton
Great pizza and wings and awesome staff. We own the condo above the restaurant and always love to eat here when we stay. The manager, Marco, is very friendly and always makes our experience an enjoyable one.
… more
Lauren Butcher
Friendly staff, but they get a bit flustered if it gets remotely busy. Takes some time for to go orders so it’s a good excuse to have a libation while you wait. Ordered a medium Yard Sale pizza and a side salad and had some for leftovers the next day. Decent pizza and a salad us a salad.
… more
Rachel Lasher
My family ate here after driving 20+ hours. We had a party of 8 on 4 tickets. The first pizza wasn’t right so, he left it and made a new one. The other three pizzas were ordered at the same time. It took a while to get one, then I had to go ask about the other two. He completely forgot to cook one of them. It was the worst service! No drink refills, no I’m sorry (mostly because he wasn’t), no comps on the bill, everyone left angry.
… more
… View more