Based on 154 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
33 Main St, Fair Haven, VT 05743
Phone: (802) 265-8121
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Morgan Rabideau
The customer service was AWFUL. I walked in and took like 30 seconds for someone to acknowledge me, which Isn’t bad, but when I went to pick up my order they had it under a completely different name. The prices online are NOT the prices in the shop. She took my card without telling me the total then when I get home realize I was upcharged and when I called back her excuse was “my website isn’t up to date” . Not even an “oh my gosh thank you for telling me is there something I can do for you” to make a loyal customer. Dough is really tough more sauce than anything and no taste of cheese
… more
Kyle Tebidor
I grew up eating grinders from this place. Absolutely phenomenal quality with one of a kind homemade rolls made in house. Owners are so kind and the pizza, and pasta tastes like it’s straight from Italy. I still make the 3 hour drive at least twice a month to get some food from this establishment. Good priced too. Highly highly recommend
… more
Andrea Doran
Best bread I have ever had! Get the hot Italian sub with the works
… more
Deven Frasier
Best subs, possibly of all time. I’ve eaten my fair share of Subs from this area and beyond. The subs are amazing and there’s nothing like them!!!!
… more
Becky Bruce
I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS PIZZA PLACE AT ALL! WE SPENT OVER $100 ON FOOD TO FIND ALL THE DOUGH HAD MOLD ON IT! THEN THE ORDER WAS NOT COMPLETE! OWNER IS VERY DISRESPECTFUL CALLING PAYING CUSTOMERS NAMES!
… more
AF 2.0
I stopped by for a slice with a few toppings. When I arrived they said I could have a single slice of whatever I wanted. Unfortunately, as shown below, that just means they drop the toppings onto the slice and serve it to you. As I was eating it all the toppings would fall off since they didn’t bake the pizza with them. I was very disappointed in this. Otherwise, the cheese pizza was good. The crust is thick, they aren’t cheap with the dough, and the sauce is very tasty as well. Since the base of the pizza was good I’m giving it two stars but the experience of just putting the toppings ontop of the slice was really subpar and not worth the money I paid. At least half of the benefit of a pizza with toppings is the added flavors that the toppings give to the pizza as it bakes, you don’t get this quality when you just drop the toppings on an already made pizza.
… more
Big Poppa
Excellent family owned pizza shop with great dough, smooth sauce and top shelf toppings. Delicious meatball parm and salads. Lucy is simply a doll.
… more
Mark Towne
Ordered a large pizza with everything on it. The toppings were generous and delicious.
… more
Jennifer Hall
First time eating here in years (moved away). Just like I remembered, the pizza is delicious, and the homemade rolls that Lucy makes for the grinders are one of a kind. My family and I will be returning again soon. Nice to know somethings haven’t changed in small town USA. Very reasonably priced.
… more
Nina Kuperby
Chicken tenders were so dry and looked as if they were microwaved. Alfredo was bland and rubbery (worse than the $1 pack Alfredo’s you can buy at a dollar store). Garlic bread was probably the best out of what I received but it didn’t even taste like garlic bread. Fries were underdone and soggy. The women at the counter even forgot to charge us and I had to remind her.
… more
… View more