Based on 318 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
117 W Main St, Middleville, MI 49333
Phone: (269) 795-7911
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–1 PM, 3:30–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1 PM, 3:30–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–1 PM, 3:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 PM, 3:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 PM, 3:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3:30–11 PM |
| Sunday | 3:30–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brook Rasmussen-Mills
The all meat wet burrito is delicious and large enough for 2 meals. It’s definitely worth the price. We haven’t dined in so I really can’t say much about the atmosphere.
… more
michael bassett
Has that small town pizzeria feel. We Had a pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza and it was great, plenty of cheese and toppings! The Lenny sticks (garlic cheese sticks) are also great .
… more
Angie
The best-tasting pizza I’ve had in a long time. Their sauce is amazing, order an extra pint to take with you for later! The good people who run the place are down to earth and friendly too. Choose these guys for your next indulgent take out!
… more
TimeKeeper
I enjoy pizza, all types of pizza. I enjoy Faro’s pizza. Faro’s pizza tastes great! It tastes pretty standard as one would expect, but they have special sauce. And they have pepsi. And when I go somewhere all I want is a Pepsi.
… more
RyAnn Herman
Awesome food in a cute little hometown pizzeria. Everything is great, from pizza to dinner dishes to their subs and appetizers! Would always recommend, to anyone!
… more
Matt
In the Caledonia, Middleville aera, this is the best pizza place hands down. Decent menu, their all meat Burrito, chicken wings spot on. Stright forward, pizza ordering nothing crazy, their crust is good, although adding a white pizza and spinach to their vegetables menu would be excellent. Pass on their potato skins. I will update as more itens are tried. Have only picked up or did delivery. Have not dined in.
… more
Deborah Sigler
This place has gone so far downhill that the last 4 times I have ordered it has been disgusting! Done wasting my money! Dry hardly anything on it pizza and the pepperoni tasted disgusting! Manicotti that had nothing in it and was undercooked on the outside. Lasagne: Maria sauce that was so thick and cooked down that it tasted burned, meat had a strange taste. Bean burrito 2 times had very little sauce or cheese, tomato and lettuce were not fresh and soggy, onion on it was not chewable. Thought I would give them another try months later and still bad food! My last burrito the week before Easter had a ton of sauce that also was very very thick and had a terrible taste. The tortilla was strange like it had been soaked in water so mushy that it was disgusting. Looked like whole leaf lettuce was laid on top and not chopped up and the onions were not chewable again. Had to scrap off. I just don’t understand how the owner can’t do better! Quality of ingredients have went way down!!! Everyone in my family agrees! Have also had freezer burned lasagne in the past, burned subs and a ham and cheese sub that didn’t even have 1 full pc of ham on it & lumpy cheese. How can 1 place have so much go wrong? It’s like they just don’t care and I have never known them to offer a refund! How can Faros even send out food that is so bad!! So disappointed each time! C’mon Lenny do better! Hate putting this on here but nothing gets done about all the bad food that comes out of there!
… more
Sam Chapman
Service was perfect, food was great. It was the perfect meet up spot for my mom and I. We had the garlic bread with cheese and a splt a 14″ pizza. We had a good experience and will be back again.
… more
Eric Syrba
The pizza came with lots of cheese on it! Can’t complain about that! Good cheese to sauce ratio. The bosco sticks were tasty as well. Good service with a nice dining area. Much better than the chain pizza places!
… more
Andrew Stambolija
You forgot my extra sauce 3 times in a row. Last week you forgot the meat balls on my spaghetti and meat balls and ordered the chef salad but ended up getting the house salad.
… more
… View more