Based on 810 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
781 Cayuga St, Lewiston, NY 14092
Phone: (716) 754-8880
Website: http://www.favoritespizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christine Smith
Little tiny place with a big bang taste. Enjoyed our meal and tasted everything. Could I complain enjoyed everything. It’s like an egg hunt to find this little place but once you crack it open definitely take a look you’ll enjoy. Steak and cheese and a chicken cordon bleu.
… more
Shaheer Shaaban (Sean)
Great food. Multiple options to choose from. Friendly staff. In a good day, they have outdoor picnic benches for the guests.
… more
Tom C
This pizza was recommended to us by family of family who grew up in the area, he said it was “the. Best.”. Stopped by on our way out of town and man o man it was delicious! Super affordable too, I was surprised, fed our family of 5 for under $30. So many unique flavors too. The honey garlic chicken was amazing and the steak sub style one. We got 1 of almost every one (by the slice) and they were all SO good.
… more
Ryan S
Recently ordered a half tray of cheese and pepperoni pizza requesting thin crust because previous orders I received were very doughy. The girl taking my order said that would be no problem. Picked up my order only to find it was probably the thickest and doughiest pizza I have ever had. The pizza was literally 90% dough. If I’m spending $25 on a half tray of pepperoni pizza, I at least expect it to be made the way I ask. Pizza is always subpar with exception to their specialty slices. Most overrated pizzeria around.
… more
Therri Payne
1st time visiting to Lewiston decided to try Favorites Pizza. We wanted to dine in. Walked in and the young lady told us we could sit anywhere. My mom placed our order at the counter. We watched at least 10 people come in, get their food and leave. No one ever came to the table with our food. After 30 mins of waiting my mom went to the counter to ask how much longer would it be before our food was ready. Only then was our food produced. We should’ve just walked out. Too bad I can’t give this place zero stars!
… more
Kat
How did this place get reviews over 2 stars? The food is absolutely disgusting. The worst take out I’ve had in a very long time. The pizza was ultra thin and burnt. The chicken wings were over fried w liquid sauce dumped on it. Even got expired sour cream packets. We ordered about $100 worth of food and threw out most of it. Out of towners avoid this place.
… more
Tom I.
We live in Amherst & have visited the Fav’s on Sweet Home Rd several times. We happened to be visiting someone in the Lewiston area, so we thought we’d bring dinner from the local Favorites. Entering the store, I was surprised at the lack of singles available. The Amherst store always has a great variety of singles available. In Lewiston, the counter staff was helpful, efficient & accurate with their time estimate. Our food was very good and similar to the Amherst store. I’m sure this store knows their local market but I would like to see more varieties in their singles next time. All in all, a good experience & we would go back when we’re in the area.
… more
Lenny Smith
One of the best varieties of pizza you’ll find around, and every flavor is great. My daughter loves the steak and cheese. If you happen to stick around, they have some tables to enjoy your slice and hang out.
… more
Tiffany Beam
We were in town from kansas city and needed a quick dinner. I did have to wait an hour for our pizza to be ready (they said 45 mins) so wasn’t huge, just hoped it would be quicker!
… more
jason lizardo
As soon as you walk into this place youre met with a plethora of smiles from all staff who clearly are excited to serve you. The first bite of my incredible 12 inch of deliciousness sub immediately took me to an even happier place, like i had an out of body experience looking down on myself enjoying every bite like it was my last with tears in my eyes. I want to say the chefs name was damani but i will change it to D-MONEY. These people know how to male some food. Im not even hungry but i might go back 2 or 3 times today. Maybe theyll hire me one day i really want to work there but might get fired from eating all the profits. I dont have any kitchen experience what so ever other than making spaghetti-O’s and feeding my dogs.
… more
… View more