Based on 244 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
9 Carolina Beach Ave N, Carolina Beach, NC 28428
Phone: (910) 458-7010
Website: https://fentonispizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Allie Pyles
Pizza was delicious! I love a good, floppy slice with lots of cheese and not too much sauce. We also had an order of garlic knots to share which were quite tasty. Service was excellent and our kids were amazed by the 80 lb batch of dough the team was dividing. The guy who took our order was super friendly and engaging telling us about the process.
… more
Danda Naveen
Nice place for a pizza after a tiring day at beach. Large plain pizza at $18 and then you can add toppings for $3 & $4.5 each. They give slices as well and they do have calzones. Place is good enough, don’t think its small byt look of front entrance with bar like sitting, they have some decent setup on the back. Fountain drinks and bottles too. Restrooms available for customers. Food is decent when its hot, service is too good.
… more
Brian Richardson
Best pizza in Carolina Beach. Rather you want to grab a quick slice, or pick up or have a whole pizza delivered, Fentoni’s has you covered!
… more
Jamie Wilhelm
Stopped here while at Carolina Beach for a slice.
… more
Josh Trotter
Walked to the restaurant from our room in CB. This is our first trip here as a family, so we are trying to find some good local spots. The staff were all really friendly and the food was great. We had a large salad and large pizza. Had a good talk with the cashier about our favorite MLB teams. The prices were reasonable, as we always stop for pizza on our first night at the beach. We had a very positive experience here.
… more
Reid Cathcart
Loved it! Excellent pizza right in Carolina Beach. We ordered delivery, and it arrived hot and fast. Delicious too! This just might be the best pizza in the whole Wilmington area. Definitely will be coming back.
… more
Edi Palau
Awesome experience! The customer service provided by Kayla and the manager Matt was outstanding. They went beyond the norm to make you feel like royalty. I highly recommend to everyone, the food was great! AC was cold and working well on this HOT day thank goodness . Definitely will revisit.
… more
Kevin McCuen
Best NY style pizza I’ve ever had! The bottom crust was thin with a slight crisp and the outer crust was beautifully done. You can get two pieces of pepperoni and two drinks for $13 total. Makes for a great light dinner that leaves room for the amazing donuts next door.
… more
Chef Joe Balli
I’ve been there a couple of times. They actually have a pretty good slice. This is coming from someone who is from Jersey and has been in the business for a long time. So I will say they definitely have one of the best slices on the island. I believe people are so used to all the generic over seasoned chain pizza that they don’t know what a good slice is.
… more
Mallory Barlow
The best way to describe this pizza is a slice of grease. Honestly, even that is a gracious compliment. There was not much flavor, and the pizza was mushy and soft. Additionally, they have fallen for what I call the “Starbucks Fail” – aka demanding you give them your name when placing an order. I guess some people think it makes it more personable, but frankly, I don’t want to give out my name, and I hate being put on the spot for it. Before Starbucks made that fashionable, places like this would use an order number. This made sense and was less invasive. Furthermore, when put on the spot for my name, I spat out a random name, the first that came to mind – and the person who took my order openly laughed in my face. Additionally, all they do is heat up old slices of pizza that have been sitting out. Frankly, if you would like some good pizza that actually has flavor, is fresh, and does not immediately give you heartburn from a couple of bites of grease-laden soggy cardboard, and you’d like professional and respectful service, I’d advise you go someplace else – literally any place, you can’t pick wrong as long as you don’t pick Fentoni’s.
… more
… View more