Based on 376 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2406 Bayshore Rd, Villas, NJ 08251
Phone: (609) 886-8760
Website: http://www.fishandfancy.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tony R
We’ve had takeout here multiple times thru the years. People may not like their system? But it works! Good is always great, along with items you can take home and cook yourself. If you’re not willing to wait for some of the freshest tastiest seafood around, get a Filet O Fish from Mickey D’s.
… more
Megan M. H.
Hands down the best place for seafood in the area! Although if I’m honest…we hardly went anywhere else. We ordered multiple times while there on vacation. Some of our favorites were the coconut shrimp and crab cakes. On Friday night we did have to wait quite a while for our food but it’s completely understandable considering how good it is.
… more
Lynn S
Great place to get take out seafood. Everything is always fresh, cooked the way you want and the prices are very reasonable compared to other seafood places in that area. They do have a place to eat outside but it is mainly just picnic tables. Their business is mostly take out. Call early if you are ordering on the weekends during the summer because they get very busy. Enjoy!
… more
S Waskiel
Wife said she will not go into the store again. Staff not friendly, no eye contact, no hello, no thank you. called her name brought someone else’s order up after she was there much longer. Said if i order from there again i go in. Didn’t feel very welcoming. Need a manager there. young staff works hard but doesn’t even make eye contact with customers
… more
Louis D’Alonzo
I know it’s hard to find help these days but the two young girls that were working on and at the register on sat afternoon have a piss poor attitude and need to be educated on how to properly serve the public (paying customer). I had to laugh bc the sign says be nice or leave. I’ve said enough, but I will say, I left this place feeling like I won’t come back.
… more
Doctor DeMento
One of the better places in the Cape May area to get quality fresh Seafood… raw and even prepared for you… and they will even cook it for you same day with enough notice. Decent prices for better-than-average Fish & Shellfish! Look at the great stuff I bought for Italian Christmas 7-Fishes!
… more
Brian Craig
I sat down for a meal after working all day, so needless to say I was starving and thought anything should have tasted good, but I was way wrong. The food quality was dismal and most certainly frozen fish. Mushy and flavorless with a hint of water. No bathroom and rude staff gets this establishment 2 stars only because I didn’t have to pay.
… more
Greg M
Amazing prices and portions! We split corn fritters, clam strips, and a HUGE portion of old bay fries and all were great. Will definitely come again
… more
Joe Costick
Great seafood! We usually do take out. Call ahead because they are always busy. Food is ready when promised. Very large platters.
… more
Susan Watts
Consistently good food. You can either take out or eat on their covered outside patio. Right next door is an ice cream stand and miniature golf for the family. We love it here!
… more
… View more