No-frills, counter-serve operation specializing in pizzas, pepperoni rolls & chicken wings. Based on 625 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1045 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park, FL 32065
Phone: (904) 276-4445
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–1 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–1 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–1 AM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–1 AM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 10 AM–1 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: fivestarpizza.com
Reviews
Sierra Bowlin
We stopped in to grab a pie while we were waiting for Vertical Motion to open and the employee went above and beyond to make sure we had what we needed because he heard me mention we would just eat in the car while we waited. He brought out plates and napkins and a treat for the kids. The pizza was absolutely delicious and the service was amazing!!! We will be back for more!
… more
SGO3795
This location was a takeout and delivery only location; this accounts for the 3 star rating for “atmosphere”. Service was prompt, friendly and efficient. We were a walk-in order and it was ready in 15 minutes. Nice sauce, great dough/crust, cooked just right! You can watch your pizza being made as the kitchen is “open concept” and very clean. Better than other local places we’ve tried.
… more
Amber Holyfield
HORRIBLE service! We had ordered a pizza at 5:00 pm, arrived to pick them up 30 minutes later and they were holding our pizzas off to the side on a shelf. We were told that they can only take cash because their machines were down the minute before we came into the store, then sarcastically asked if we had cash on us. We weren’t notified that their machines were down at all. We then left and called the place to speak to the manager, Rachel, who was the same person who treated us unkindly in the store too. We were also mocked by being told that they don’t give out free pizzas when asked if a check could be taken as an exception. I definitely do not recommend coming here to order pizzas. Very disgusting service. Bad, Bad, BAD! She was supposed to have the owner, Robert, call us back but we have yet to hear anything from him. They have lost a good and loyal customer in us being treated in this manner
… more
Stephanie Pagan
I would’ve taken a picture of the pizza but it looked so good, we tore it up pretty quick. It was AMAZING. The crust is incredibly good. Like crisp outside but doughy inside. The wings were well done which was perfect. We just moved up here from South Florida and we just found our new pizza spot.
… more
Martin Shumate
Best pizza around. When request extra cheese you actually get it. Generous toppings. Wish delivered to Oakleaf area, but it’s worth the drive to pick it up. Great job guys! Thanks!
… more
Katie Williams
So we have never had an issue with 5 Star, but tonight was a disaster. I have no idea what the driver was doing, but this pizza shifted big time and now I have mush.
… more
yulonda pettway
Friendly staff! Quick service! & The food is worth every bit the money! The pizza ingredients are fresh and the garlic wings are perfectly seasoned! 10 out of 10!
… more
E
Ordered the pizza, was told 45 minute delivery and then got a call back saying it would be 2 hours. Went and picked it up, the location I picked it up from was absolutely disgusting. The floor was nasty, the place reaked of mold and the person handling the register or the person picking up the phone went right to the pizza handling the ingredients and making pizza without washing their hands. DO…NOT…RECOMMEND! THE…WORST…PIZZA… I’VE…EVER…HAD!
… more
Mary Ploettner
WHAAAT??? Literally paid NOTHING for a DELICIOUS mushroom pizza!!! Got a coupon in the mail, didn’t have to buy anything else, 100% FREE pizza!!! Will ABSOLUTELY be going back! Staff was SUPER friendly and welcoming! Thank you!
… more
Andrew Cartwright
This locations management is very vindictive. I asked for extra teriyaki sauce on my wings. Not teriyaki chicken soup. Also a few weeks prior to the teriyaki soup that they thought was appropriate, I order a Buffalo chicken pizza. They ran it through the oven so fast the cheese did not melt and the pizza dough was not cooked. both incidences happened with one of there managers Jake.
… more
… View more