No-frills, counter-serve operation specializing in pizzas, pepperoni rolls & chicken wings. Based on 947 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
3325 Plymouth St, Jacksonville, FL 32205
Phone: (904) 388-8879
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–12 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dustin Ryan Shaw (D star)
I order from here about twice or more a week. However I do order here at least once a week on pizza night (which is payday, because I can definitely afford it when I’m freshly paid). Other times during the week when I get it more than once, is usually because i got a tip.
… more
Stephen Rodriguez Jackson
Everything tasted absolutely amazing! Mild wings and and everything pizza! Service was awesome given I ordered about 20 minutes before midnight. It didn’t take long at all. And everything was made to perfection. I asked for the wings well done and they were exactly that, not too burnt, but not too undercooked either. And the pizza was great, just missing the garlic butter crust I ordered, which is an honest mistake and I still give 5 stars in hope next time they don’t forget it. Definitely my new go to spot for pizza!
… more
whitney alexander
Pizza is fabulous. BUT if you can get what you actually ordered it would be a miracle. Last two times ordering my order was completely wrong. Most likely due to the fact that the people answering the phone do not know the menu and pizza specials. And every time I go there the people helping are high as a kite and cannot function.
… more
Ashleigh Lenderman
I definitely cannot complain. Ordered online and had a gift card they placed on my door around Christmas time that didn’t have a code, so I informed them in the special comments/delivery instructions. When they got to my house they honored it with no problem. Pizza was fresh and hot when it arrived and very cheesy, which is obviously great! The garlic butter knots were good as well. Will definitely order here again. Delivery was also fast as well and the driver was very polite.
… more
rkjw
i order 5 out of 6 nights a week sorry i like pizza lol tonight on 5/14 i called at 11:15 and was on Hold and nobody ever picked up if they look up my order history they will see i am a Valued Customer But for Nobody to pick up the Phone when the Recording Tells You Wait For the Next Associate is AWFUL after 45 min I want Management or Corporate To Contact Me !!!!!!!!! Plus As Much as i order i have not been offered Discount and i order every night……. Tell Them My Name is Rick They Will Know Who i am At Plymouth St
… more
Dominic Briggs
Tried to call and order a pizza and got left on hold for 20 minutes and then I hung up and called back and someone hung up in my face and then I tried to call back again and they left me on hold indefinitely. Whoever is at that store right now definitely needs to get fired.
… more
Pat Williams
I ordered the “Everything The Kitchen Sink” Pizza & OMG, it was absolutely delicious & so filling. This to me was so much better than my beloved Supreme Pizza. I will order this again & the Delivery Woman was so courteous when she brought it! It was nice & hot too, not cold. My neighbor orders their “Chicken Wings” alot & that’s her favorite! Thank you Five Star Pizza & Hopefully down the road, you’ll add the stuffed crust Pizza’s to your menu (Just A Suggestion)
… more
Benjamin Aguillera
This place is the bomb!. Their pizzas, wings, pepperoni rolls, and desserts are sooo good. I’ve enjoyed their food and service for over 25 years. Keep up the good work!
… more
*VioletsinBloom *
They use to make really good buffalo chicken pizza. I dont know if this location got a new cook or they changed the way they make it but this is like the 3rd time ive ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and its super soggy as if the buffalo sauce and ranch was put on after the pizza baked. Pools of ranch and buffalo sauce sitting on the pizza. It soaked throught the pizza making it appear and feel like some slop and the sauces were running everywhere making a mess smh so soggy that when we picked up a slice half the slice stayed in the box.
… more
Pete Kimmel
Beware of the disingenuous, dishonest marketing and bad customer service from 5 Star Pizza. I was mailed a $10 “no strings attached” coupon in the mail and called to redeem it on a large pepperoni pizza carry out special, which I think is about $12. The guy on the phone says no, we can’t do that because then the pizza would be free for you. Are you serious? Then don’t send me a no strings attached gift card! I attached a picture so you can see that there is no language on here that disqualifies using in on top of other specials, or anything. That is literally what no strings attached means. The call made me feel like I’m just some freeloader trying to take advantage of them… not someone who has ordered hundreds of pizzas from them in the past. I don’t understand the strategy of mailing your customers a Holliday gift card only to ruin the goodwill by being a cheapskate and making up restrictions because you dont feel like redeeming it.
… more
… View more