Based on 27 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
LaGrange, IN 46761
Phone: (260) 463-2352
Website: https://www.fivestarpizzami.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Deb Sailor
Found this family-friendly place while looking for pizza. We ordered mozzarella bread sticks, pizza, ultimate nachos, and chicken wings. It was all very good. They have homemade cheesecake that looked delicious, too, but we were full after everything else.
… more
Tanner “Cornfed” Miller
Only ate here once I’m fairly picking on my food reviews. If your around lagrange and want pizza this would be my first pick. My pizza was a little under cooked still good would definitely go back
… more
Carolina Wierzbowski
excellent pizza, fast service! Crust is fabulous, wide choice of toppings. Family run.
… more
Corinna Burkholder
Delicious food, great service, slightly obnoxious, loud music.
… more
Tara Galloway
Amazing pizza, highly recommend. Not the cardboard tasting stuff, sauce and crust is great, we opted for flavored crust. Very friendly/caring staff, took almost 20 mins for two pizzas and breadsticks during dinnertime. Clean restaurant. Ended up getting cheesecake as well when we picked up. Definitely will return
… more
Bauera2 B
Best pizza around in my opinion! Great hand tossed crust.
… more
Anthony Miller
Although we had a rough start with our order not actually getting put in for about 30 minutes. The restraint realized their mistake and made up for it and got our food out quick. Really friendly staff that cares about their customers. Pizza isn’t the most amazing but still a pretty good meal!
… more
Tracy Miller
Ordered carry out. Very good pizza and the cheesie bread is amazing
… more
Kari Lipscomb
We order from here regularly and have always enjoyed good food and service. The wings are very good.
… more
Joshua McGuire
The pizza dough wasn’t cooked fully in the middle and barely had any sauce.
… more
… View more