Based on 198 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
112 E State St, Colon, MI 49040
Phone: (269) 432-3214
Website: https://www.fivestarpizzami.com/colon
Hours
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Reviews
Tori Thompson
We are not from the area and thought it was a restaurant with beer, when we realized it wasn’t we decided to take the pizza to go, so we placed our order as a carryout and waited for it. Definitely a mistake not calling it in ahead of time, they are busy before 4pm! Good for them! We love to see businesses thriving!
… more
Katrina Jackson
Love the pizza… travel time for me is 25 minutes but will travel that for really good pizza …food is always done right… always hot and fresh when I get there
… more
deb oliphant
I ordered a calzone. When i opened the box it was swimming in grease!!! I went in and told the yound man about it and he said “thats how our calzones are” so…..only order if you like wet greasy calzones. That appears to be the way Five Star makes them!
… more
Stephanie Smith
Wanted to try something new . Worst experience. First was told It would be 35 minutes. Turned into 45 minutes. Paid by card ,wasn’t told that they charge 3% to use card ,found out by the smallest piece of paper on the counter while I waited the extra 10 mins for my pizza. Get it home and even more disappointed. No sauce,the little bit of toppings we got were falling off before the pizza made it to my mouth. Very disappointing . Will not be visiting again.
… more
Biggy Big Mountain
Magically the best pizza around. Love visiting and looking at all the memorabilia hung on the walls and bookcases. They even have a piece of my family on the wall. “The Amazing Conklins” crate on the wall was part of our stage show.
… more
Lee f
Twice in a row, can’t get pizza order correct. Never again. Used to be good, something changed, poor accuracy.
… more
Charles Wagner
Old Town feel, great food! The people are the best too especially since everybody know everybody . But if you are from out of town, best dang pizza place in southwest Michigan!
… more
WallStreet Bets
Always hit this place up every year! The crust is best I’ve ever had!!! Sauce could be a bit sweeter but still was great! Pepperoni had so much flavor again best I’ve had! I would give this a 8.5/10. Fix the sauce add a tiny bit sweeter easily 10/10
… more
Matt Smith
Had to wait 45 mins to get a pizza with no sauce and hardly any toppings…then they don’t bother to tell you that they charge 3% more to pay with a card….this is my first and last time here
… more
Jane Eckert
Leaves people wait on hold for extended periods of time. While waits on whoever is in front of them. I thought I could order food locally on my way home and pick it up, keeping it local. Instead I had to walk in to make my order. Good pizza, service…
… more
… View more