Based on 413 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
4957 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501
Phone: (845) 373-8178
Website: https://fourbrothersrestaurants.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J Vatell
Very cute set up on a nice corner spot. Head inside the restaurant for inside dining or stay outside on a beautiful patio and order snacks, apps and other light fare. Food is always delicious, great portions and menu has a ton of options. Never been but there are movies played on a drive in screen behind the restaurant. Seems like it would be a super fun night out!!
… more
Anthony DAgostino
Great Italian food and pizza! We had the meatballs appetizer and shared their Brothers Pizza. Everything was delicious and well made. The service was great and the place was very comfortable. Excellent choice when in the area!!
… more
Jacqueline Chen
Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients.
… more
makayla shearer
My fiancé and I came here with our 4 month old for lunch and the outdoor dining is very authentic, the food was delicious not to mention I asked for a side of marinara and they came out with a soup bowl filled with sauce! The wait staff was super friendly and made the experience even better which is why it deserves 5 stars!
… more
Rich Clark
Had a great experience and loved their Lobster Roll !!
… more
Caitlin Bedell
Not to be obnoxious. Called millerton by mistake. Sat and waited for food. Nobody questioned it. 30 minutes. I obviously got upset didn’t understand different location. Restaurant manager for many years I get it. I paid for half of food from other location . Told staff enjoy food I paid for. Owners son still learning it’s a hard business. I am sorry if I went overboard with anyone. I just expect certain things and will always pay and take care of service
… more
Brandon Newkirk
Dropping my daughter off at camp and stopped for local quick bite and found this place. Basic food nothing special but nothing “bad”. Restaurant depot food warmed up. Pizza was fresh but was not a fan of the sauce but the crust was nice a soft texture wise. Quick and easy but not worth price.
… more
Jeffrey Donlin
First time… amazing food. Went as a family, great atmosphere food was very very good. Service was one of the best ever experienced. Highly recommend. Easy parking located in the center of a quaint small village with a few shops. Very nice !
… more
Carmen Gonzalez
Me and my Mom went in on a Sat night around 8:00 on our way home from NY. There were only a couple of other patrons there. You seat yourself, I grabbed a window seat. The waitress came right away with the menus and drink order. We ordered a small veggie pizza. The pizza was yummy. I had to flag down the waitress for a refill of soda and extra napkins, which I should’ve of had to, as she only had 1 other table. Nice atmosphere, except the fake hanging plants those definitely should be taken down. I noticed they have a small private dining area right as you walk in to the left, and they also have a drive in movie area in mid-winter months. I will definitely be back when in the neighborhood again.
… more
Aniko Magyar
Unbeatable food at unbeatable prices! Friendly staff (mostly young local trainees with about two senior waiters thrown in). Bathroom small but spotless. The venue has a welcoming, homely feeling, and can accommodate larger parties. The vestibule has several local announcements posted, and there are local newspapers/publications for pick-up. There are about four beers on tap, and several on bottle. Prepared foodstuffs are retailed by the cash register. Outside there is ample private parking, and a drop-box for donated clothing.
… more
… View more