Easygoing family-operated eatery offering pies with creative toppings plus pasta, meat & seafood. Based on 340 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
279 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-0080
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Parthiban S
Outdoor ambience alone deserves 5 star. We ordered few slices of pizza, wrap and chicken Alfredo on spaghetti. Be aware their quantity, it’s huge. The lady who served was very kind. All that cost only 65 bucks.
… more
Alyona Rabukhin
A very mediocre place. The beet and fennel salad wasn’t any good. It was tasteless. It was 3 of us, the food got delivered to first person and then in about 15 minutes we got the rest of it. Why? The staff was nice though.
… more
Peter Casbar
Best Italian food around! I really can’t say enough about how delicious the food is! The pastas are incredible and cooked to perfection! (Not overcooked like most) the wings are incredible and the pizza has so much flavor! The service is fun and very friendly. We took ours home this week but the patio is very chill and comfortable. Been going for decades and the food is even better than ever! Great prices too! Happy to have this place in the neighborhood!!
… more
Chris Putignano
I love Frannys! The tipsy grandma pie and the hot roni are my two favorites. It’s your classic pizza joint serving up some of the best.
… more
David Farrell Jr
We stopped in as we were passing through and it was a pleasant experience. There is no direct table service. You order at the counter and then they bring your food to you. I was kind of confused by this system because I observed food brought to the wrong table several times. The pizza was good. My wife thought the sauce was too sweet but I thought it balanced the saltiness of the cheese well. The meatballs were very good. They were tender and delicious. Unfortunately they were not a consistent size. We got a huge one and tiny one which was kind of annoying because they were expensive in my opinion. The price of the pizza was reasonable on the other hand so it made up for it. ***Feedback for owner, please find a system of tracking orders to tables since there is no true table service. Maybe consider table numbers or some other simple system.
… more
I Dellaportas
We dock our boat close by and wanted a quick bite to enjoy while waiting for sunset, came across pizzeria. Knowing a lot of the places close by. Never tried it and boy so glad the attitude of the girl answering photo did not change our mind (attitude and kind of rude)
… more
Max Oro-Hahn
The place looks nice, but not a very good option. Servers were mildly unprofessional and laughed off when we complained that a few dishes came 15 mins after the first ones. I understand it’s meant to be more of a casual restaurant, but service is mediocre for the prices they’re charging.
… more
Shubham Bhawalkar
Wonderful hot pizza after a walk on the beach, among the best I’ve had in a while. We tried a custom dine-in large one half with hot honey, jalapeno, basil and other half with garlic, ricotta and eggplant and both were a blast! Would highly recommend this place <3
… more
Christopher Brown
Got carryout here and it was so good and the menu so deep for an inexpensive Italian pizza place that we decided right away to eat here again the next night. Great sauce, cheese, traditional crust. Also, we ordered another pizza with extra sauce, light cheese and they nailed it perfectly. Pasta cooked to perfection; excellent red sauce and alfredo. Nice flounder, mussels, and clams. Generous portions. Very quick carryout (like 20 min for a huge order). Only regret is they were out of tiramisu, but it was right after the rush of the Highlands Clam festival, so not surprising. My new favorite casual Italian place when visiting northern NJ.
… more
Eric Jonathan Martin
Ate here while visiting my family and not only was the food excellent but everyone had a great time! There is indoor and outdoor seating during the summer so you can find the best spot. Their vegan pizza options are fantastic, and the regular pizza is just as great!
… more
… View more