Long-standing Italian restaurant specializing in brick oven pizza, with private dining available. Based on 139 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
480 NJ-35, Red Bank, NJ 07701
Phone: (732) 747-4737
Website: https://fratellispizzeriamiddletown.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Maria La Freniere
Staff is friendly and welcoming. Love… Love… Love the pizza. I came in for slices. I’m more of a veggie, thin crust person. To my delight, most of what they have on-hand is thin crust offerings. Very fresh and not oily. I have a thing for picking up the slice and not wanting to see oil drip down from it. If you’re like me, then this is the place to be.
… more
David M. Dwight
While working Medic Unit #1202 stopped in for 2 slices that were very delicious.
… more
Prince Vegeta9000
I’m sure this will go on unheard ears. But the staff here aside from a couple girls have terrible customer service skills everyone is miserable even after I tip on a Togo order they still don’t say thank you. I’m sure they work off tips so they are prone to just being nasty cause the owner pays them nothing but jesus not even a smile. The only one I see smiling is the owners daughter. But she comes to work in a 100k mercedes suv must be nice. Nasty rude people most of them.
… more
Pat Bolin
After the Nutcracker we went to Fratellis in Middletown , absolutely wonderful service from our waitress Ashley , good food . Would strongly recommend. Thank you to Michelle the manager for making the reservations smooth and the perfect ending to a perfect performance of the Nutcracker!
… more
Nancy Hill
I usually get a thin pasta with marinara sauce. The pasta is perfectly cooked and the marinara sauce is the best I have had since moving out of a predominantly Italian neighborhood. It is oil, plum tomatoes, garlic, basil and made fresh everytime. The bread is perfect as if it were baked on the premises. Then they have the best Tartuffo!! Really rich..plenty for two. The service is always excellent!! Friendly and I feel like I am family.
… more
Kerrin McCarthy
Ordered a drunken grandma and got the saddest pizza. Hardly cooked through, super thin crust, little splashes of sauce that hardly covered the pizza. Wings and mozzarella sticks were soggy. Very disappointing for 40 dollars.
… more
Rohit Shirodkar
Loved their white cheese tomato & garlic pizza. The portion size is quite large. We ordered a small pizza for two of us. Still had 4 slices remaining. My daughter ordered half fried chicken sandwich. It came with two six” pieces. She could only finish one piece.
… more
Joe Lynch
Placed a delivery order to Atlantic Highlands (10-15min away) on a Sunday night. Was told it would be an hour. An hour and half later was told it was out. Over two hours later driver shows up. I cancel order and tell him bring food back as it’s two hours since order was placed. Woman call from restaurant rudely demanding to know what the issue is. Well we called twice so you are aware of issue. YOUR SERVICE IS HORRIBLE and YOUR STAFF IS UNPROFESSIONAL.
… more
Marty Diaz-Verson
We ordered take out. The staff was very helpful, the delivery driver was prompt and very polite and their pizza was amazing. We ordered pepperoni pizza and mussels in a hot marinara sauce. This is going to be our go to place from now on!
… more
Bridget Fisher
My family moved to this area about 2 years ago. We decided to try this local pizzeria and see if the pizza was any good. We were totally surprised by how much we enjoyed the homemade meatball pizza. We were even more surprised by how much this restaurant had to offer. I have never had a meal from here that was not delicious. Their $5 lunch specials during the week are always filling and delicious. they have a great selection of dinner specials on the weekend with plenty of variety for the customers. The restaurant is family owned and operated and they take the time to get to know their customers names and even come to visit the tables to see how the customers are enjoying their dining experience. I would recommend this restaurant to all of my friends and family members.
… more
… View more