Based on 218 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
35 50th St, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 478-6800
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rosalie Fittery
I order take out. Arugula salad $11. Margarita pizza $19. Please see pictures & decide for yourself if it’s worth it
… more
Ashley Anand
Amazing! Came right as they were opening on a Sunday early afternoon. Bruschetta: hands down best we’ve ever had! Better than Italia!
… more
Michael Justin Porco
A wonderfully authentic Italian wood fire pizza restaurant! Those reviews saying the waitress was nasty probably has never been to Italy or interacted with a native Italian. Our waitress was very nice but didn’t speak English very well. She was kind and smiley but comes off a bit cold. Just talk to her! We asked her opinion on her favorite pizza and she was very nice. Anyway, the pizza was FANTASTIC. Exactly the way you want your wood fire pizza to taste. Crunchy but not at all burnt. Would highly recommend. FYI, they don’t serve alcohol but bring your own bottle and they’ll uncork it for you (and not charge a fee!).
… more
Joel Bernstein
I would give 3.5. We ordered takeout and that was super easy. Pizza was cold and we picked it up as soon as we got the text it was ready. Seems no effort to keep warm since it was just sitting under the counter. Then we ordered a variety of mushrooms pizza, barely any mushrooms and they were all baby bell. But once we toasted the pizza it was crispy good flavor. Keep it warm and for $23 put a variety of mushrooms as advertised.
… more
Shea Stanislaw
This is the Margherita pizza nuff said and the calamari was not good either… maybe off season bules but that was a waste of 80 bucks
… more
Winter White
Sat outside, ordered a pizza which came out hot, cooked well and delicious. Good sauce, fast service and friendly. Great place for a good pie! Would go back
… more
Tara Irvine
Ordered three pizzas through Slice at Fratellis. Two were correct, one was supposed to be spinach ricotta and tomatoes and it came filled with meat. Called and they said they would redeliver and never showed. Disappointing. The pizzas that we did get weren’t even fully cooked on the bottom. Mass produced and low quality pizza for sure. Buyer beware!
… more
SpringtimeReturns dotcom
The pizza is seriously amazing. The best in sea isle hands down. Not too expensive either. The salad could have been more plentiful (for example, the caprese needs another bunch of arugula) however the pizza more than makes up for it. I gave it a three on atmosphere and service only because the staff aren’t as warm as I’d like. At the end of the day, food is amazing.
… more
jaritza mulero
I went in this evening with my aunts and our waiter was so nasty to us. She didnt even give her name. I kindly asked her if she can cut our pizza again as we could not even with our butter knife. She got nasty with us like I already cut It. My aunt dropped her plate trying to cut the pizza.We were discussed with her services.We will never recommend this place to anyone.
… more
Rudolph Rigano
Watch your order carefully. We ordered takeout pizza and even though we walked in and picked it up we were charged an 18% gratuity. This 18% gratuity also included the tax. We are usually big tippers for good service but what service is there to walking in and picking up a box of pizza. and then to charge a gratuity on the tax was a real issue
… more
… View more