Based on 277 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
120 E Main St, Gas City, IN 46933
Phone: (765) 573-6033
Website: http://facebook.com/gabriellas.otp
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 1 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 1 PM–12 AM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tim Ziegler
Gabriella’s Old Time Pizza has more than pizza! Nothing wrong with their pizza, but there’s lots of places with good pizza. Instead, my wife and I decided to order sandwiches (meatball, and ham & cheese) which turned out to be really good. We’ve only ordered a couple times before, and this was the first time we didn’t get pizza.
… more
Steve Ott
Wellllll… if you like incredible food, this is the place for you. Is it good?! Considering the fact that my husband and I now go 3-4 times a week & no longer need to buy groceries, I’d answer that with a YES! Consistency incredible. No, I’m not exaggerating. The Stromboli is my absolute favorite. My husband is obsessed with the Indiana (similar to a Cuban- but better). Honestly, I’ve tried about 10 dishes and I would get every single one of them again. Run, don’t walk. WORTH EVERY SECOND OF YOUR LIFE. SO SO SO GOOD. & if you need someone to go with, my husband and I will gladly join every time.
… more
Holliday Hobby Talk
Food was AMAZING!!!! BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA AND SUBS AROUND!!! Gabi and the staff were also very welcoming and the whole place had a positive vibe. 10/10 easy
… more
Kristine Wardwell
Came here Thursday 5/25/23. I got the chili cheese dog with frito chips. The beef hot dog was okay. You could tell dog had been sitting awhile. The chili was award winning? Don’t know what award it won, but wasn’t good at all. The chips did nothing for the dog. And the bun was just to much. Also got a lemon shake up. It was pretty much a lemon water. Gave this place a 3. Most likely won’t be back.
… more
Brittney Wilson
I had my pizza delivered from Gabriella’s all the way to Marion! And let me tell you this is by far the best pizza I have ever tried! It’s outstanding the service when Gabi ( the owners wife) answered the phone she had such a sweet personality that was infectious, yes even though our interactions wasn’t long it still made an impact. The pizza was so good!!! The delivery driver was very kind as well! If I could give you all 500 stars I definitely would! Will for sure be ordering again!!!!
… more
Andrea Huffman
Ordered for a birthday dinner and waited nearly an hour and a half for one pizza , one breadstick order and some sauce. After calling to check on the order, I was informed it hadn’t even been processed at all yet?……….. Please warn customers if they have to call and prompt you to provide the service you were PREpaid for.
… more
Dee Reese
My husband and I went to Gabriella’s to try out their pizza. As we drove up….Loved the decorations outside and well as inside. Every booth had a TV and a wonderful atmosphere to sit and enjoy your food in. One young lady took our order and she was very friendly, very nice! It was not overly busy, so we sat down to wait. After a while, my husband says, “I am so hungry now.” I mentioned, has it been a while now? It felt like we waited 30 minutes before walking up to the podium to ask about our food. Our pizza was down on a table, the sandwich was off to a side, and the breadsticks were not boxed yet. I’m not sure what happened, so we paid and went home. Our pizza was not warm. Crust reminded me of eating a cracker, and toppings were not very good. After reading the reviews, maybe it was just an off day.
… more
Connie Sturgeon
When we first ordered a pizza, it was delicious. We started getting pizza 3 or 4 times a month. We told all our friends how wonderful it was. Friday’s pizza was like eating cardboard. No cheese in the hand tossed crust and it had very little flavor. We were so looking forward to a wonderful pizza and we ended up being very disappointed.
… more
Katie Bowersock
My family and I had a great experience at Gabriella’s Old Time Pizza. It’s a little further off I-69 than we expected, but the food made up for it. We tried their regular crust, thin crust, breadsticks and wings. My daughter had the wings as her meal. They were a good size and seemed to have plenty meat on the bone. The regular crust was not overly thick, but was a good crust not satisfied my children who prefer a regular / thicker crust. My husband and I had the thin and it is truly THIN! As a type 1 diabetic, I appreciate that as it helps my blood sugars to have less carbs involved with pizza (which is a challenge to dose for as it is). We chose to try the bold sauce on our pizzas, which the waitress described as not spicier at all, just typical marinara but with a stronger flavor that you could taste more. She said she preferred it. We enjoyed the taste, and would almost describe it as slightly sweet. I truly enjoyed this small local pizzeria. It’s worth a stop! The waitresses were also very friendly, and the inside of the shop is small, but well maintained. Each table also has its own small mounted TV with Netflix or Hulu options, but no sound (can use closed captioning).
… more
Anna Lewis
Still had half of our pizza left,got to car realized we forgot it ,went right back in and the girl had already thrown it away! Why wouldn’t you wait a little bit or run out to us. Guy was very Apologenic and offered to make us bread sticks but we didn’t want bread sticks we wanted the other half of our pizza that we paid $30 for! Place is very dark inside, was hard to see menu. Second visit here, first time got regular crust. It was good, this time got hand tossed, it was like cardboard. Definitely won’t be a third visit.
… more
… View more