Lofty, late-closing parlor serving creative pizza, Italian sandwiches & draft beer. Based on 347 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
104 E 6th Ave, Tallahassee, FL 32303
Phone: (850) 765-4120
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–1 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ehrin S
This was a nice place to try. Kid was in the mood for pizza. I wasn’t. Fortunately, their pizzas can get so far away from traditional pies, it’s basically different experiences on flat bread. This is not meant as an insult, they really thought out of the box pairing flavors and it actually works quite well.
… more
Tierra Lee
Tried this place with my family as they recently opened this location. We had three 10” pies as well as garlic knots. Everything was absolutely delicious and fresh. My father-in-law’s pizza got caught on the chains in the oven and had a huge hole in it. Not only did they come out and tell us, but also made his pizza again AND gave us a complimentary order of garlic knots for the inconvenience. All of the staff was so polite and courteous, it felt like we had been there many times before despite being our first time. I would HIGHLY recommend this location and WILL be returning every trip to Tallahassee.
… more
Steve Estes
My wife and I have been patrons of the Gaines Street location for about two years. The combination of Gaines Street Pies and Oyster City Brewing is outstanding. I’m happy to report that the trend continues here in midtown. Get you a pie and walk over to Ology for some delicious craft beer. My pie tonight was candied jalapeno and Italian sausage. Every bit as delicious as the Gaines Street location. I paired it with a Czech Pilsner from Ology and it was bliss. Also big shout out to the garlic knots. I’m very happy with this new location.
… more
Robinson Rodriguez
As I bit into this calzone, I was immediately hit with a sense of befuddlement – how could it be this good?! It had the most appealing cheese pull: visually stunning, scrumptiously tasty, indulgently aromatic, perfectly hot, and satisfyingly crunchy. All five senses were stimulated, and thus it gets a deserved 5 star review. Thank you Mae and Midtown Pies, and thank you Sunburn Cannabis across the street for making this happenstance be included in my life’s highlight reel.
… more
Gregg Lantz
Stopped by for some takeout. Parking was a little challenging but a simple pass around the block was enough to allow a spot to free up. I had ordered ahead and just needed to run in and grab my order. My order was ready and hot when they promised. The crusts are formed in a press which makes the dough lose its structure and makes it a bit chewy. I found that you can place the pizza in your home oven for ten minutes and crisp up the outside of the crust making a delicious pizza even better.
… more
Gary Sokolow
This is the latest store of the local chain. The pizza called the white album is particularly good. It’s next door to a brewery. The next time, I will sit at the brewery, but bring the pizza over to the brewery. I heard that that is cool and a lot of people do it
… more
Craig Benner
Delicious. Five adults. Two pizzas. Almost a whole pizza left over. It was huge. XL. Tasted oh so good. I will be ordering from them again. I am not a fan of filling up on the crust.bi want the other ingredients to shine. The crust has to be great. But not filling. The ingredients were fresh. The cheese was tasty and not fake. It was delivered on time. Loved it.
… more
Ashley Barber
Fantastic pizza, chewy but still crispy crust, a variety of sauces and some really interesting toppings.
… more
bravokidroxy
Thin crust, not as crispy as I usually like but still really good. The atmosphere is loose and small town. They are reducing their use of single use plastics so the straws are only available upon request and the cups are made of sturdier, dishwasher safe #5 plastic.
… more
christie c
Pizza by the slice or a whole pizza, there is no wrong way to enjoy Gaines st pies! They have endless toppings and the staff always goes above and beyond with their customer service!
… more
… View more