Hand-tossed pies, salads & subs at this local chain outpost with a lunch buffet & delivery. Based on 220 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
116 N Plymouth Ave, New Plymouth, ID 83655
Phone: (208) 278-5300
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cassandra Hampton
Hey there! I normally don’t post reviews. But I went into this garbanzos today and I ordered a small pepperoni pizza with half jalapeños, and I received a medium pizza with barbecue sauce, chicken, and fries. I wasn’t too concerned at first I just thought they gave me there wrong pizza but when I talked to the lady at the counter she gave me the dirtiest look ever and didn’t offer to remake it. I took the pizza but ended up paying 3 time the amount for it. Just disappointing!!
… more
Connie Crowe
Garbanzo’s has the best pizza I have ever tasted! They make a homemade crust, add plenty of cheese, toppings, and just the right amount of sauce. The place was exceptionally clean and the staff was awesome. The painted ceiling tiles were done by the talented staff and adds a great personal touch.
… more
Jaren Weber
Are you ready for an unforgettable taste bud extravaganza?! Then get ready and buckle up for a once in a lifetime pizza party. Take everything you thought you know about pizza and throw it out there widow, while your senses are tantalized by these mouth watering flavors! A sauce that will put all other sauces to shame. Cheese that will leave you pleased. Fixing problems, one slice at a time! Garbonzo’s pizza is the 8th wonder of the world and the best kept secret in the United States.
… more
Steve Schiffer
Great small town eatery. Really enjoy their sandwiches. Their ice cream is a fantastic reason to wander down on a hot day.
… more
Krypt Keyper
Clean establishment. Bathrooms are kept clean. Background music isn’t too loud. Reasonable prices. Basic salad bar with one time serving or all you can eat option.
… more
B_FRANCE_208
As a former lunch lady I had personally seen 2 health code violations when I went in to pick up my order. First, and kid came out from the back with gloves on, proceeded to wash his used gloves and went into the kitchen to continue making food. Second, another kid who was working in the kitchen and running the register was handling money and the computer with used gloves on. I paid cash. He handled my cash and with the same gloves went to the back and handled food. Do they not know what cross contamination is? I am a local in New Plymouth and we don’t have very many food options, so to have this happen I will not be going back. I will drive to Fruitland to get my pizza now.
… more
Kris Blevins
First time trying the French fry pizza and the was so good
… more
ronald jacoby
Small but delivered big. So happy there is a Garbanzo’s in New Plymouth. Great food and service!
… more
Chris Litton-Merrell
So back in 2009-2011, I went here for lunch pretty much every school day. It was epic, the food, the service, it was just amazing. I was gone for 6 years before I came back a couple of months ago, and I have to say I am super disappointed what the NP store has gone to. I went in today(Jan 26, 2019) for my lunch break. My wife called in an order at 11 a.m., and they said it would be done BY 1130. We went in at 1130. Exactly. I went and paid for my food, and after having my debit card tossed back at me, I went to sit down and wait. Why? because they haven’t even started making the food yet! We got two sandwiches(which were thrown together haphazardly) and a lunch special. 10 minutes later, the little high school aged looking girl says “its gonna be another 5 minutes.” 15 MINUTES later, we finally get our food. 45 MINUTES AFTER IT WAS ORIGINALLY ORDERED. I get that place can get busy, but there was not that many people in there for one, and for two, we called 45 MINUTES EARLIER for that fact alone. My point is that ever since I got back, I have gone probably 4 times and every.single.time The service has been slow and so bad I have been seconds from getting my money back and leaving. Today was the last straw for me. I will not return, I will not spend any of my money there and I will no longer tell others they should go there and try them out. This store has become an embarrassment to the brand and to the way things used to run all those years ago. I hope the owners see this, read this, and take action to restore their NP store back to being the epic, great service place I spent SO much money at way back when. Because at this point, I wouldn’t even send people I hate to eat here.
… more
Cayson Howard
The pizza here is good. They have an amazing lunch special last time I went that was a good price. The only problem is the pizza here is very greasy. I have had a couple times where a single slice has so much grease that it took a few paper towels to get rid of it.
… more
… View more