Old-school place offering classic Mexican fare & a variety of margaritas, plus frequent specials. Based on 673 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
139 Main St, Cortland, NY 13045
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Melissa Fox
Absolutely GREAT place to eat! The food is Absolutely AMAZING! The staff is friendly! The prices are average. I highly recommend the Taco Salad with Chicken! It is so good!
… more
Kayla George
Went to Garcias for the first time tonight, the environment was welcoming and warm.
… more
Marleah Tkacz
*Portions are large and the food is both fresh and delicious! It was our first time so we weren’t sure what to expect. Lots of food options on the menu (although my husband was sad there were no tortas and no cecina). The tortilla bowls for the beans and rice were a creative serving idea, too.
… more
Dawn Tacopina
My daughter and her fiancé just moved to Cortland and we decided to try. The staff could not have been friendlier, and we each got a different meal and were completely impressed with the amount, presentation and taste. Just fyi, the Mexican pizza is a FULL size pizza, not personal size, but so fresh and yummy
… more
Loki Laney
Wonderful food. I moved from Austin, Texas to Colorado and now Upstate New York and have been searching for years for a restaurant that would fill the void that tex mex left and this fits the bill. It immediately tastes like something I could have gotten back home in Texas, which is to say delicious. 10/10
… more
David Gow
They give you chips and salsa to start with, we added Quac for $4 and change. They were little stingy on the Quac and chips. Its ok we’re all having tuff times. I Had the chili verde and that was very good. My wife had the taco salad and she liked that. Place was clean waiter seemed upset because he was only waitstaff on all day even though there was only 2 other tables to be waited on while we were there.
… more
Laura Curry
After looking for lunch for HOURS and trying several places (covid has very much affected the restaurant industry), I found THIS gem. A smallish family style mexican restaurant. It looks unassuming from the street, but let me just say. HOLY WOW were myself and my significant other blown AWAY. From the 1800 tequila pitcher of margaritas to the queso and the DINNERS Even the refried beans were drool worthy! It wasn’t very packed when we arrived and only three staff to be seen out front. The waitress was very kind and moved quickly and efficiently. It filled up quickly, and given that it was a Sunday afternoon, we took this as a great sign. All of the hours of waiting and driving and getting hangry were SO worth it when it came to this gem! We will MOST definitely be back as this is our new favorite Mexican restaurant. Thank You Garcia’s!!
… more
James Siegrist
Sooo… It caught on fire and was heavily damaged… I have no idea when 9r if it will reopen…
… more
J Mullen
I have visited this place twice and each time I have had a great meal and wonderful service.
… more
Brandon DiFalco
Food is very good but they are short staffed. Worth the wait.
… more
… View more