Based on 182 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1135 NY-9D, Garrison, NY 10524
Phone: (845) 424-6447
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chris Schneider
Pizza is good … but not bad for a slice of a pie or maybe two out here great place to stop
… more
Ashley Weyer
I’ve been going here since Covid. I love their pizza! Thin, crispy crust. Great flavor! Recently had chicken parm pizza and the chicken was so good. It was very well seasoned. Highly recommend this place!
… more
Ryan Moffet
I stopped in to take lunch. I ordered a meatball sub I sit down and I see it the breads are amazingly fresh. I’m enjoying it at 1st until I realize the meatballs are raw so raw that I have to run outside and throw up I then go to tell. The manager or the man behind the counter is a younger gentleman, middle age. And he acts like I’m just making this up to get a free meal, which clearly offends me because you can clearly see the meatball. Is raw I don’t just throw up for no reason? If it was not for the cook, the older gentlemen, a nice Italian fellow, he deescalated the situation pretty well do apologize for my language but. Still you’re not gonna make me out to act like I’m trying to get a free meal when you can clearly see the meatball is raw. Atmosphere was great in there up until that moment.
… more
Joel Rowe
Don’t be fooled, this is the best pizza in the area by a landslide. Most comparable to Joe’s in the city, truly wood fired, old school style. Reviews about staff etc are missing the point: this place makes great pizza. Not on Doordash etc but well worth the short drive.
… more
Ashlee Boteju
Love coming here for lunch and fellowship, beautiful day out, great food!
… more
Willy Giang
My gf and I stopped here after a hike in Cold Spring and we shared a pizza half Margherita half veggie and it was pretty good! The young girl who served us was very nice.
… more
Vit Yasen
Italian place with fresh and tasty pizza and other stuff. Ordered very strange soup (spinach and egg). That’s why 4 starts
… more
Tom Dudley
I stopped in when taking a trip in the area, good selection of different types of food the pizza was thin and real good, I would go back
… more
Gabriel Willow
Shady place – on the couple of occasions I’ve been in here, there were only one or two old-looking pizzas congealing behind the glass. The sandwiches skimp on the fillings. The [I presume] owner is bizarrely rude and hostile – one time I brought an entire group and he was so rude we all left. I had the coffee and a sandwich; the coffee was terrible and the sandwich didn’t seem fresh. I ended up throwing both away. I also noticed the rude owner guy handled food without gloves, which is disgusting. Avoid!
… more
JoAnn Norris
We stopped in after doing a hike in the area. Not a full service restaurant. You order & pay at the counter. Small inside, about 5-6 tables, but there is some outdoor seating. Menu posted on blackboard. Pizza was excellent. I had the broccoli rabe & bean soup. It was yummy.
… more
… View more