Based on 73 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
28811 S Tamiami Trail #5, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
Phone: (239) 221-3112
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brooke Pelt
So so so good!!!!! I am thrilled that Bonita Springs finally has an even better Gatsbys Pizza then the previous one, that was fabulous, but this… Oh my goodness! The pretzel bites and beer cheese, so good and the Pizza, well, it doesn’t get better than this!!! Yummy!!!
… more
Katie Fogarty
When I walked in with my bf for our valentines date, we thought it was the cutest place ever, with tons of sports regalia and a sign supporting FGCU. Jackie and Sandy were so sweet, asking our names and checking in on us, asking how we were, if we needed anything and sharing a bit about their struggles, like a friend who has brain cancer… it felt like we became part of the family of the restaurant, just from having a few interactions with the staff and other customers. The food was just as good. We thought we would get a large pizza and save some for leftovers… the two of us ate the entire thing because it was so good. Definitely can’t recommend enough. I’ve never wanted to give a tip as big as we left here. Will definitely go again.
… more
Anna Bauer
What a great spot! We ordered a pizza and some cheesy garlic bread for takeout, and it was ready super fast. The pizza was delicious, with crispy crust and plenty of cheese and the garlic bread had extra sauce for dipping. The staff was SO kind and went out of their way to accommodate us, and I wish we would have found this place sooner during our trip. The inside is really cute – I love their decorations. If you’re going to get the garlic bread, definitely get it with cheese! You won’t regret it.
… more
Jenna Wu
I saw someone post on Facebook about this place and wanted to give it a try! The lady that worked there was super friendly (owner). Think it is a husband and wife that runs the restaurant. Go Buckeyes! They are from Ohio which I am too! The pizza was really good. Each slice had a good crunch to it and loved the taste. I like how it is cut into tiny squares and is thin sliced.
… more
Marc Kipp
This is pathetic. $10 LG salad that barely feeds 1 and a $20 pizza that looks like it has been sitting out since last night. Very disappointing and will never go back. Pictures speak for themselves.
… more
Sharon Winne
Fantastic Pizza!
… more
David Conde
A wonderful little Gem on Bonita Beach Road. The minute we walked in we were welcomed to this family owned establishment by the friendly staff. Jackie, the owner was in the kitchen making the meals even on her birthday. Her husband and co owner Greg, was not in today, so she had her dear friend assisting with the order to go and sit in customers. Not only did we enjoy the margarita pizza but we truly enjoyed meeting other customers who are regulars and had a wonderful time eating and hanging out with the everyone. As people walked in they all knew eachother, which made the experience even better. I got to meet a Fellow Mets fan and chatted it up about our team as if we have been friends for years. They are within 5 minutes of Bonita Beach so on our next trip to the beach, we have found our spot to enjoy great tasting pizza. We heard their salad is just as good. Cant wait to get back out there.
… more
Ashley McGuffin
Ok, this is just the cutest mom and pop pizza place. Mr. Greg and Ms. Jackie are absolutely precious people with an incredible story to share. Pizza and cheese garlic bread was tasty. Mr. Greg prayed a blessing over our meal. Listen y’all. Excellent service. Sweet people. Yummy, cheesy pizza thin crust style. Give this place a try!
… more
Joseph Murphy
Edited the original Review to 3 stars from 1 because the owner responded and tried to explain and apologize. I did use the slice app and it let me place the order at 7:30. Moved to 3 stars and will try again when we visit the area again. Pizza could be great just never had the chance…………”Tried to call to order at 7:30, they said you have to order delivery online, ok so I order from their 3rd party website at 7:30. They close at 9:00 and I see Freon my bank website the canceled the order at 8:45 and never delivered dinner. No call or message”
… more
Steven Bailey
Everything about this place is amazing. The inside is small with just a couple tables, but has a nice comfortable atmosphere. The service was great, and the staff were super friendly. The pizza was hot, fresh, and delicious. Would highly recommend Gatsby’s!
… more
… View more