Based on 98 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
19 E Main St, Pawling, NY 12564
Phone: (845) 855-3200
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
C Parent
This is one of the ONLY places we’ll get pizza from. The pizza is always delicious, and the garlic bread Parm is also amazing. And the price is always right! They are always friendly when we come in. We absolutely love this place.
… more
Sheebs
Casual dining room. Yummy food. Very friendly owner with authentic Italian background. Street parking.
… more
Tyler Ronconi
I don’t normally leave reviews, and I feel bad because the people were nice, but maybe this can be a wake-up call. This was the worst pizza I’ve ever had, with the exception of a place in the state of VA (no surprise, the south sucks at pizza). We were served display slices that were so old, stiff, and rancid, it was disgusting. Only could stomach a few bites before we threw away, paid, and politely walked out. It was bad. Even the garlic knots were rancid, sour, and spoiled. The ricotta on a slice was rotten, stunk, and crust as hard as a rock, not from overcooking, but from staleness. If they weren’t three weeks old, they looked and tasted like it (or worse). We stopped here because we were in a hurry. I used to run a pizzeria, so I should’ve known better when I saw the sorry condition of the display case. Usually I’m not picky so I thought, why not, I just needed fuel. But I had a premonition when I walked in and went against my better judgement. I don’t know how they stay in business if this is what they serve up every day. Hope this little family-run place can get it together and turn it around. My heart aches for businesses during this trying time (especially with a fraudulent usurping idiot in the White House). It’s tough to make money when costs are high and food margins are slim, but this is inexcusable, serving rancid, old food (beyond rancid). Nothing personal, just an honest review that may help.
… more
Sean Boyd
A surpringly tasty and filling slice, without being bread or doughy. Pretty quiet inside with lots of room to dine in. Aim for the nice corner table with the bumped out windows overlooking the slow pace of quaint Pawling Village.
… more
Richie Hernandez
At this time of age who doesn’t take credit cards? Food was ok nothing special but cash only really sucks. With Covid and flu season who wants to touch money.
… more
Upstate NY
Great pizza. Loved it. I grew up in Jersey, worked in NYC for a few years, then moved to Connecticut. Now I moved to Pawling and tried out this pizzeria. I know good pizza. This place definitely had a great pie. I will be back to try out other things.
… more
Wanda Rusiecki
This has been my family’s go to place for 15 years. We love their calzones, packed with whatever ingredients you choose, and their veggie slices. Great value for portion size. Eat in or take out. Great family owning the place, check it out!
… more
Tom Meyer
The best Pizza and local Italian food . His Meatball and Eggplant parm wedges are amazing .
… more
Frank Matheis
Dino makes the best pizza. I would love to eat more of it but for medical reason I can’t eat it anymore. Today we have guests and I am picking up two pies for the kids. How I wish I could eat it again, because it is absolutely delicious and perfectly made. My family and I used to stop in all the time, so good!
… more
Vlad Rud
I stopped here after doing a section hike on the Appalachian Trail. Pizza slices are big NYC style thin crust slices. The entries were huge and tasty. I’ll definitely visit again if I’m in the area.
… more
… View more