Based on 79 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
901 Franklin St, Toronto, OH 43964
Phone: (740) 337-4551
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Gem-City-Pizza-Toronto-OH-622606004598688/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Justin Shay
The sweet and spicy pizza is amazing. Paired with the swag sauce, it takes it to a different level. It’s definitely a favorite in our house.
… more
Google Reviewer
Their calzones are the best. They’re completely different than anything I’ve ever had in the valley. Almost like a super soft loaf of fresh baked bread stuffed with your favorite toppings. And the Pepperoni rolls are pretty similar. Those are their top 2 menu items imo.
… more
Angela Reneè Leoni
This was very good pizza. My 1st time, I will be back.
… more
Eric Hazen
One of the few places that’ll deliver in this cesspool of a town. The food is alright. I’m not a huge fan of Ohio Valley pizza, but their calzones are good. Their roni rolls do the trick too. The Italian sandwich was sad…Love that they deliver though! Keep it up!
… more
Darren Jones
Unsanitary, watch when you order from here I’m just now coming down off a stomach virus everytime me and the wife order from here we end up getting sick some way.
… more
Scott Maddox
Visited a Gem City Pizza in Myrtle Beach, SC, several years ago. Loved it and visited several times during vacation. Learned that the owners were from Toronto OH. So when I came thru Toronto on business and saw the sign I had to stop. Fantastic experience – just what I remembered. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten anywhere. — sweet and spicy tray was incredible. Will come back whenever I’m in the area.
… more
Ron Peach
A few years ago this place had the best pizza to be had in Toronto or anywhere else close by. But after changing owners a few times i think, it went downhill and was not very good so I quit buying my pizza there. After reading some re ent Facebook posts with people claiming that Gem City Pizza is back, i gave them a try tonight. So, are they back? Well, sort of. My pizza was decent but not on par with the way it used to be when it was fantastic. Hopefully they will continue to improve it. Mine would have been great if it woild have had more sauce. I would definitly recommend giving them a try!
… more
Natalie K
They put No cheese on the pizzas and the crust is always hard and overcooked. New ownership is cutting corners. not ordering here again.
… more
Shawn Mousourakis
Guy running the cash register had no clue about prices and couldnt read the register to give me the correct change. He then went from handling the money to making dough without washing his hands. Then another employee can in and started cooking without washing his hands. Pizza took over 20 minutes for 6 pieces and was just terrible. I was then hasseled by another employee on whether i paid or not and the employee who took my money couldnt seem to remember. I will never even think about this joint again. Frozen pizza is a better option than this place
… more
Victor Churchill
Was a great place when I first moved here, then they changed the crust like a cracker not the best
… more
… View more