Casual Italian restaurant known for pizza also has pasta dishes, subs & appetizers such as wings. Based on 964 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
1419 McCarter Hwy, Newark, NJ 07104
Phone: (973) 481-6900
Website: https://gencarellispizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kevin Dufresne
Unless Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches is an in-house entity like I learn of another store of which I’m unable to find a location on Google/Yelp because of it being like an in-house entity, I don’t know what’s going on with Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches having the same address as Gencarelli’s Pizza Factory. Even so, I’m leaving à good review for Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches. I like subs. I like a good sandwich, yes, though cold subs particularly. Now, being in New Jersey AND Vegan, I’m glad about discovering Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches. I order The Reuben which is tasty though I don’t mind a little more vinegar, salt, and pepper on a Reuben. The entire sandwich is firm-soft. I’m curious about the way other sandwiches might taste especially since Vegan meals can differ in taste so much per brand and/or type of Vegan meat. The Reuben travels well (tasty after about thirty minutes).
… more
joseph jenkins
They’re pizzas are the best and town. I just wish they had stayed in the location. Where they was, it was nice and quiet. Dial is right off. The highway it is hard to get to.
… more
Brian Kernan
I walk in and ask for a plain 14 inch pie and guy hands it to me in about 5 seconds. Truly the pizza factory. And it’s a top quality pie. Cheese is superb and the sauce very good. Chewy/doughy crust but not too thick. It’s a very good pie. Classic North Jersey/NYC style. And of course the prices are impressive. Just $8 for 14 inch plain and $7 on Friday I believe. Used to be $5 and $6 Friday specials. Needless to say no one beats this. No seating. It’s about the pizza not the glam.
… more
Brian Durant
This is a hodge podge of restaurants not just Gencarellis this place has maybe a dozen plus “restaurants” the kitchen is cooking for. And as far is the pizza goes its bad everything there seems like its missing something there food isn’t filling at all kinda like eating air. The service is great but the food and price for what you get isn’t correlating. Do yourself a favor and PLEASE just pass up on this place your better off either not eating or eating air.
… more
Dowry Valdez
Excellent pizza my kids love it but prices are going up as usual every where that they start low until they get famous and they increase their price. But I still want to buy it for my son who loves to go there for Italian
… more
KevLar Da Don
First time ordering from Gencarelli’s. Probably will be my last. I ordered the Stuffed Shells & 8pc Buffalo Wings. The pasta sauce for the Stuffed Shells was not tantalizing at all. The Shells themself were not good at all neither. The Buffalo Wings were extremely salty and inedible. First time in my adult life I didn’t finish Buffalo Wings. I paid $32 for the combo, and it was not worth it in any way, shape, or form. The total should have been $12, maybe. Hopefully they’re better known for their Pizza, rather than their dinners, but I would def not be trying this place again. Only reason I give it 2 stars is because I was expecting it to arrive in “1.5 Hours”, but it came in 30 Min. Def could not give it a recommendation to anyone. My first experience was not a good one at all.
… more
Joel Rivas
Waited over 20 minutes when the food was promised at a certain time it was not. Order the New fries dipper, was not impressed, I was given a bag of grease fries had no potato taste to it. Will not be ordering here again. Check your food quality!!!!!
… more
Star’s Creations
I paid $11.00 for an extra large pie and $10.00 for delivery. The pizza was a soggy and sloppy mess. The crust was paper thin and undercooked, no crunch at all! All I tasted was the extra cheese and too much of it! Big disappointment, I used to love this place. What happened? Smdh.
… more
Nena Rodriguez
They used to be good. Pricing is up service is down and the pizza is not the same. Better when they were on bloomfield Ave….
… more
Ravi RG
This is no longer the same pizzeria with their famous 16″ x-large pizza for $6. The prices you see on their website is for a 14″ pizza – $8 for a plain pie with taxes or $10 for a X-large 16″ pie. So yes the prices have gone up drastically. Additionally, the x-large pie is only actually 15″, it is much thinner, and has much less cheese then before – like 40% less. The tomato sauce is the same – very tasty and the heart of the pizza. One person can now eat a whole X-large plain pie given it is so much less substantial than before. SAD that the place has raised prices so much while reducing the quantity at the same time.
… more
… View more