Based on 178 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
Address:
424 Oneida St, Rupert, ID 83350
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Amy P
Great service and atmosphere. Set up is clean. Their pizza is SO dang good and the salad bar is the BEST! The one and only complaint I have is the pasta can be a little dry/bland sometimes.. but they’re still 5 stars in my book!!
… more
Friday Cook
I really love their pizza. My experiences have been with take-out ordering, so I will praise the waitress/cashier for going out of her way to pour cheese into the containers when there were none ready to go. She ordered my pizza the way I requested and the cook made it ‘to order!’ Excellent! I will return.
… more
Toshia Cooper
I just went and ordered 2 pizzas for takeout with the new cauliflower crust. Absolutely amazing pizza! Cauliflower crust tastes exactly like regular pizza crust. Super thin the way I like it but only crusty on the outside edge. I had to go gluten free 2 years ago and this is the first real pizza I’ve had. As long as Gertie’s keeps the cauliflower crust we will definately be having pizza more often.
… more
Daniela Gomez
I love coming to eat here when I want all kinds of pizza the service is always great I love their soup and pasta. I also like how they have a lot of choices for their salad bar their pizza taste so good especially their desserts! It’s always fresh and warm.
… more
Raylee Ann Reeves
Very ok service. The pizza was once really great but has gone down hill. However, if you want a desert pizza, they have the best. Go for the Reese’s for a nice delight. But to impress the guests, go for the Oreo!
… more
Derrick Huestis
Their pizza is delicious, I advise you go here instead of pizza hut which is on the other side of the parking lot. Been here twice so far and I love it. My only advice to them is having a heat lamp area where they can keep the pizza’s for a short time so if we like something we can go back and get another slice. (they walk by ever 5 mins or so with a new pizza or desert). When you pay for your meal (unlimited slices of pizza) they let you request a specialty pizza if you’d like, but honestly by the time it comes out you will probably be full on all the other types of pizza that went around lol
… more
Alicia Christensen
I wasn’t thrilled with the time it took for our table to be offered any pizza. We have small children that watched the same table over and over again get served. It took 30 minutes for our table to get our first slice. We went for my son’s birthday. It was a flop. On the plus side their dessert pizza is awesome.
… more
Jeremiah Owens
Dont get me wrong, the pizza and salad bar are good but when you literally get only 5 pieces of pizza in an hour, it sucks. My wife asked for a certain type and the waitress said it was actually coming out of the oven. Well 36 minutes later it still never arrived .We finally had to get up and leave .The staff was too busy laughing and talking in the back for us to get their attention.
… more
brasmussen81
Unless you really, really like ranch, I don’t suggest you go. They used to have more of a variety but the last 3 times we have gone it has gotten progressively more towards only serving ranch pizzas. This last time we went, the only non-ranch choices were the two dessert pizzas. If you like ranch, go and enjoy yourself. If not, I would look elsewhere
… more
Lynn Crane
Salad bar looked like the veggies had been sitting out all day. Brown and limp. Blerg. We have been waiting about 20 minutes and so far no pizza in sight. Soup and pasta bar is empty, with the dirty pans sitting there all dried up. There was a scoop of something and it was cold. 2 stars is simply because the service we had last time was slow, but the pizza is tasty. Probably won’t be back, which is sad…
… more
… View more