Based on 155 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
408 Central Ave, City of Orange, NJ 07050
Phone: (973) 678-7777
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9:45 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
KevLar Da Don
The other day I ordered, GiCarli’s Pizza, for lunch. I got their Chicken Bacon Ranch & Buffalo Chicken Slices. I thoroughly enjoyed the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice. It was surprisingly light and had some pretty decent flavor. The Buffalo slice was fairly middling though. The sauces could’ve been blended a little better and the chicken could’ve had a little better of a texture. The crust on both slice had a really airy and soft crust, but held up pretty well too. Their staff was fairly attentive as well and made the ordering experience seamless. Maybe would try their other options, if possible, they have pretty quality ingredients. Check this place out if you’re looking for something quick and is in the Orange area.
… more
Plo Plo
I was looking for a local mom and pop pizza spot near my home. I am happy to have come across GiCarli’s Pizza. Wanted to play it safe so just ordered two regular slices and a Cesar salad. I was extremely happy with the slices. The flavor and texture was were amazing and it was not full of heavy dough. Nicely think but still enough dough to give you that NY pizza feel. Excited to order a grandma pizza as well as a Mediterranean pizza.
… more
Nicole Ascione
There’s literally one piece of eggplant on this sandwich and it’s super salty.
… more
Pedro Escobar
Amazing slices and great size at that . I had the pepperoni w/ bacon !!! And it was scrumchest !! Def better than masters pizza down the block. !!!
… more
Knockout73 from tha brickz
Great food, and they have a which is great and you have to try their’s buffalo chicken pizza…
… more
Anthony Cortez Vera
I get their Caesar Salad often since I was very pleased the first time I got it with its delicious shaved parmesan. They usually add a couple of their own baked bread bites on the side and I love how soft and fresh these are.
… more
Tsunami Cisco
Cheese pizza is a hit and the chicken party pizza is a fave so is the shrimp scampi pie even tho that scampi pie can be a little over greasy it’s still delicious af!! Also they need to revamp their hot wings. I bought 20 wings one day and said fry them hard and shake them in the hot sauce. Do you know I got a hot wing soup basically? All my wings was sitting in like 1 inch of sauce like forreal?! I would definitely not get their wings again
… more
Solange Louis
After reading the reviews I was shocked to be proven right regarding the rude customer service, but I decided to give it another chance. This time, I was greeted in a very professional manner and was pleased with service. So much so that I called back for a name to add to my review. Surprisingly it was the owner and he addressed the last experience I had incredibly well. Antonio, the owner, asked for the date and time of the last transaction to ensure he corrected whoever it was that took my call. The food is delicious so it’s definitely worth the try!
… more
Prince Black
I religiously order a large chicken parm pizza from GiCarli. I watched the price climb from $21-$24 and I still paid, but today they tried to charge me $29 for a pizza just a few weeks ago I paid $23 for. They’ve forever lost my business.
… more
Dio Mar
Yo I ordered chicken fingers and fries and this is what I got. Not worth your money. Pizza ain’t even that good and I’ve had that too.
… more
… View more