Based on 93 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
57 Kirk Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: (631) 483-5116
Website: https://website–7320171432121933828111-bagelshop.business.site/?m=true
Hours
| Tuesday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Saturday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Monday | 6 AM–3 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jessieh Ruth Averitt
Food was excellent! Busy place, be prepared to wait in line- not the kinda place to swing by with kids or dogs in car as it does require placing order at counter and waiting at counter and there is limited street parking available during peak times. Food was well worth the wait and the process, quite fluffy fresh bagels!
… more
Stephanie Alegado
It can get super busy in here but it’s totally worth it. My favorite sandwich is the Spicy hobo.. definitely worth the wait so don’t let a line out the door scare you off.
… more
Colin O’Shea
Had 45 minutes before leaving for my 10 AM ferry and ordered one bagel with cream cheese and one ham egg and cheese sandwich. Never received an update and food never came. Had to leave to my ferry without breakfast. Place is a disaster, food looked mediocre. Avoid.
… more
J I
HIGHLY OVERRATED! If it wasn’t for their monopoly out east they wouldn’t stand a chance when compared to any other Long Island or NYC bagel establishment. Places are always overcrowded and to just get a bagel will require 30 min of your time.
… more
Nicholas Rine
This place has good breakfast sandwiches and bagels. Their service on the other hand is painfully slow. Although they’re extremely busy most of the time so I gotta give em a bit of a break on that. I had the Hobo sandwich and it was pretty good.
… more
Kim Hammerschmitt
Bagels and spreads are great..service, not for lack of work ethic, was slow…I attribute ot to lack of help..
… more
Allie Stone
I felt like I needed to chime in and write a review because I was hesitant to come here based on other reviews but it’s right behind the place we’re staying and it’s pouring today, so bagels it is. As a North Jerseyan, I have really high expectations for my bagels that a solid 95% of bagel places don’t live up to. This was not one of them. The bagel was perfectly crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, the way it should be (but is altogether unattainable for most places). They got my annoyingly particular order correct and we were out the door in 5 minutes. Coffee was fresh and strong. We’re here in Montauk for another two days and we now know what breakfast will be.
… more
Daniel Donohue
I’m very impressed by Goldberg’s upgrades. They’ve always had delicious bagels. Their deli is as amazing and delicious as any top NY deli. Staff has vastly improved and everyone that has helped me is super friendly and helpful.
… more
Jerry Gee
Picked up breakfast & lunch to eat on boat ride back from our fishing trip. It’s walking distance from Miss Montauk dock. The breakfast sandwich was great as well as the wrap which held up perfectly in the cooler (I did place it in a zip lock bag). It’s now part of our routine for fishing trips.
… more
c bocca
If I could give less than one star I would. This is not my first bad experience here. Maybe I am just glutton for punishment. However, every time I come here if you enter the store at any point the staff always seems very annoyed that you came in. Not to mention if you come in after 12 o’clock noon they are very annoyed because they’re already cleaning up for the day. They never listen to anything you order and they always give you The things you don’t want on your sandwich. Most of the staff is constantly on their phone using their earbuds talking in their native language which is not wrong, However it is rude when you have customers. For the price they charge the server should be 10 times better an accurate. This is definitely my last time since there are better delis that have better quality food in Montauk.
… more
… View more