Based on 425 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
245 N Columbus St, Sunbury, OH 43074
Phone: (740) 965-6000
Website: http://www.goodfellazpizzeria.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Star Baker
Wow!! This place is absolutely FANTASTIC!! Regular crust is thin and delicious! Sicilian crust was thick like Detroit style but not greasy and is truly amazing!! We are about 2 hours but we will be back for more!!
… more
C H
First few times we ordered pizza from here it was great! That’s what kept us coming back anytime we wanted pizza. The last few times, either burnt, way too greasy (grease coming through the box) or cold. Not sure what’s changed, but very disheartening. Time to take a break and try something new.
… more
ItsKYRO13
I was driving thru Sunbury for work and just happened to spot this driving by and stopped for lunch. The portion for the lunch special was big and very filling, and it was delicious! I am absolutely coming back. The guy who took my order had great customer service as well.
… more
Ethan Zuber
I’ve been getting Good Fella’z pizza for at least 10 years now. Their pizza was good 10 years ago and it’s even better now. A Sicilian style pie and the BFT (bacon feta tomato) pizza are my current go tos. The garlic butter base on the BFT is special.
… more
Tim Kerns
Friendly service, and the pizza was ready on time and correct. Typical Columbus style pizza. The cheese and sauce combination had a weird taste. Also didn’t appreciate having to wait in a makeshift metal tunnel to pick up my order.
… more
Bruce Carey
The people seemed really nice, but I just didn’t care for the taste of their pizza
… more
Chris Wells
Stopped here driving home old school taste mushroom pepperoni cost $11.50… Small area to eat outside.
… more
Betsy Dilger
I was overcharged for 2 subs according to the prices advertised under this listing online for Sunbury Oh and the Mgmt said they have No Control over those listing. Then Someone should get Control over False Advertising if that’s the way they choose to do business Online!! It won’t be me ordering again when they are going to raise their prices and charge what they want other than what is posted!!
… more
Baugher Family
Our family got the chance to try their pizza and stromboli tonight. The kids thought the pizza (half cheese, half pepperoni) was good but that the crust was a bit too crispy. But they are used to Pizza Hut… 🙂 My husband and I shared an All the Way stromboli and really enjoyed it. I also liked the flavor of the Parmesan on the crust.
… more
Nate Sexton
If you are willing to pay the price it is delicious! Even has a good gluten free option that I have heard from family is excellent! Would recommend.
… more
… View more