Based on 229 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3313 Chili Ave Suite 2, Rochester, NY 14624
Phone: (585) 889-2940
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
bryan mastowski
Took over 1 1/2 hrs to deliver a large pizza and a regular sub …
… more
Joanne Azzopardi
We only tried the Good Guys Pizza. The pizza was fresh and tasty. The price was also good for what we got. We would definitely go back if we lived in the area.
… more
Ari L
First time ordering here. Pizza is tasty, but we only live a few mins away and the pizza was cold by the time we got home. Guessing it was ready and sitting before it was picked up. Also the slices were different sizes.
… more
Andrew Schubart
Recently moved nearby, and this pizza place was recommended to us. Got pie and some cheesey bread sticks, we thought both were excellent. Will definitely be going back.
… more
Katie Vishnevskaya
We ordered a sheet pizza (half white, half pepperoni and onions) and 20 wings. I specifically asked for the wings to be cooked 25 minutes and no less. I was quoted an hour for my delivery. The food got to my house 30 minutes past the quoted time, the pizza was NOT White pizza, it was regular cheese pizza. The wings were so soggy and gross. Needless to say I gave them a call back, the phone rang and rang for 15 minutes. When someone finally answered they told me they were closed. I asked to talk to the manager ( he was trying to be helpful but the owner in the background wouldn’t let that happen) I asked to speak to the actual owner. When the owner got on the phone, he told me he doesn’t believe me that the order is wrong and they weren’t going to remake it. He said bring the food back and maybe I would get a refund if he approved of it. I asked for the food to be delivered for a reason because my kids are home sick and I wasn’t packing them up in the car just to please the owner AFTER an already terrible experience. I asked for the owner’s name and he told me I didn’t need to know it. Then he said “it’s BOB! my name is BOB alright?”
… more
Alan Michael
Great go to spot for epic steak bomb subs gotta get one whenever my wife and I are in town
… more
John Krystan
Worst pizza and wings ever. I’ll never buy from there again.
… more
Jeffery Meisenzahl
Good Guys is a joke of a business that is Mickey Mouse run! Order a buffalo chicken finger sub for delivery showed up with no sauce and tipped the driver $5! Had to drive to them to get my money for the 5th time them messing an order up because they can’t get it together. The “manager” wouldn’t come and talk to me made this girl refund me for the sub but not the delivery. Absolute joke! Worst pizza shop in chili!
… more
Mary Dziuba
I tried to order a sub with no meat and the girl said nope we don’t do that. You have to have me. Really just throw some lettuce, she gave me a sprinkling of it, cheese, banana peppers and tomatoes a little oil and mayo. It was dry! Roll was not fresh and fell apart. Sorry to say worst sub I’ve ever had. On the other hand my husband got a steak sub and enjoyed it. He will be ordering again. I definitely will not.
… more
Kayla Russo
I’ve been buying the sheet pizza and bucket wings(40) for months now. Can’t beat $60 for all that food AND the food is AMAZING! Feeds my family of 5 for 2 days. Tastes like pizza from back home in NYC , probably better. Wings are my FAV! BIG WINGS! Never had and issue with my order and I’m sure if I did they will fix it with no problem. Their customer service is A1, even the teenage workers are polite and very respectful and professional. Which is why my family and I decides to add them to our weekly budget and get pizza every Friday. Thank you Good Guys, for the great food and remarkable customer service.
… more
… View more