Based on 709 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
959 NM-314, Los Lunas, NM 87031
Phone: (505) 916-5654
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael Cooke
Surprisingly good pizza, just because of the out of the way location. Service was very friendly and genuine. We got 2-1 topping pizza and 2 liter special, crust was amazing, plenty of cheese and toppings. Side salad was fresh and tasty. Inside dining area being a little dated is the only negative from this really good pizza place. That will in no way keep this from being our new favorite restaurant in Los Lunas. We can’t wait to try other menu items, and there seemed to be quite an extensive menu to choose from. The place got pretty busy for lunch rush on a Tuesday, so I don’t think this place is exactly a secret. Good job, Goodfellas!
… more
Jennifer Morris
The service is this place was the worst i have ever experienced. The lack of customer service. The employees not only were rude but seemed as though as we were interrupting their world. The pizza was good, it could have been cooked a little longer but a good flavor. Toward the end one of our party spilled a drink, we asked for a mop again that was asking for too much. We cleaned up the mess. Once done here comes an employee with attitude & asks us to get up so she can clean up the ice under the table. I honestly have never been treated so rudely. I even cleaned up our mess. These employees should have to go through extensive Customer Service training or better yet maybe unemployment could be a good lesson. I really hope something gets done with this review.
… more
Mary Huneke
This restaurant is the best of the best. I can’t believe this place doesn’t have a line around the block. I have loved everything I have ever tried at this place from salad, pizza rolls, and garlic knots, wings. And the desserts are to die for oh my goodness. Yummy. If you haven’t been to this place you are missing out and you need to go as soon as they open. It’s always amazingly clean and the decor is awesome very much like a Mafia movie. The staff is friendly as well. Prizes are reasonable for how much food you get the portions are huge huge huge.
… more
Brandon Marhal
Served hot, fresh and XL 18-inch pizza measured in at 18.9×18.3.
… more
D. G.
Absolutely awesome supreme pizza. The slice is large and delicious.
… more
Tracee Coiner
This place is absolutely disgusting and very disappointing. The inside is very dirty with none of the arcade games working and the tables, chairs and floor is either dirty, worn or down right ripped. Which also makes me wonder about the kitchen .The food was ok but not even for the price. 35 bucks for 2 sub par calzones….no thanks The staff was rude as hell! I was treated like I was disturbing them or I had some nerve to walk in. I will never ever be going back!
… more
Jay
We ultimately went there for arcade games. To my son’s and my surprise three of the seven (give or take a game) games were working. Thankfully the pizza and the last chocolate chip cookie made up for their lack of entertainment. Their deep dish was thick, hot, crispy and pillow-like (where it needed to be)! The sauce tasted fresh. The cheese pull was epic. My son and I highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie. It’s chewy center, crisp edges and no lack of chocolate chips to satisfy a chocolate craving as well! So, if you’re lucky enough to get one? We did, haha (in my best Dr.Evil laugh). I hope you enjoy it as much a we did. The atmosphere needs a update. But all in all, great food! A big thank you to the staff as well. I dug the waitresse’s Slipknot shirt as well. Thanks again!
… more
Anthony Vigil
I enjoyed visiting goodfellas pizzeria I was recommended from my brother to try it out and I live in Albuquerque Heights so it was quite a drive but it was well worth it. I would highly recommend this pizza joint for their wings on Tuesdays you can’t beat the price especially the quality of the wings nice and crispy with just enough hotness to them. The pizza was just like any handmade pizza nothing too special, but there slice are portion extremely well. I would recommend this to family and friends. My only concern about this place is that it’s not being kept up maintenance or properly clean. Example dirty countertops and let’s not forget that this was when they open at 11. The walls were dirty and filled with food and soda stains, wiring hanging out of the wall and the list goes on. I would recommend is the owner of this location to give it a good walk through but besides this very good quality food nice customer service and let’s not forget good pricing nothing extremely pricey.
… more
AJ
We ordered 2 large wise man pizzas, wings, and salad. The Service was wonderful. Would highly recommend this place for catering or just a good lunch!!
… more
Charlie Holmblad
I live within arms’ reach of one of the major pizza cities of the US, that being Chicago. Taking that into consideration, my expectations are different when I travel. I stopped at Goodfellas because they were open later than most other spots in the area. I was glad that I did. Aside from the fact that the calzone is absolutely enormous, it tasted incredible. The crust was crispy and dripping with garlic butter, and I wasn’t limited to the fillings/toppings (I asked). Go here and get this.
… more
… View more