Local chain serving specialty pies plus wings, subs & Italian dishes in a modest space. Based on 274 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
120 E Main St, Carmel, IN 46032
Phone: (317) 848-1969
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 3–7:45 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11:30 AM–8:45 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8:45 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–8:45 PM |
| Saturday | 3–8:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Toni Rismiller
The absolute worst experience ever! The order was completely messed up. Returned the food and waited on correct order. I ordered two salads with extra dressing and two orders of bread sticks with extra cheese. The 1st delivery was 1 salad ( the container was 1/2 full). The bread sticks were old and cold. Called the restaurant talked to an extremely rude teen that suggested I was lying. Then talked to a male that pretended to be a manager. He said he couldn’t do anything about the messed up order. I placed this order on their Website. The delivery kid is employed by Greeks as well. This “pseudo manager” said the driver did deliver the correct order. He left it at the door of the surgery center. ( the delivery instructions was to call my cell phone when they arrived and a nurse would come out to pick up the food from them). The diver called on the 1st delivery. The driver did not call when he delivered the second order. Another nurse went to the door to check if the food was there while I was on the phone with the “pseudo manager”. The order was delivered and left on the sidewalk. Yes…….the side walk!!! What part of that is remotely ok? I asked for the owners name. The kid admitted he wasn’t a manager. The second delivery included a second partial salad and the same cold hard old bread sticks. This kid said I have to call slice to resolve this issue, even though I ordered on Greeks Website and their employee delivered the food. This is the 1st time I’ve had a negative experience with this place. I’m not sure if the standards have been lowered or the owner doesn’t know the shenanigans his night shift employees are up to. In addition I paid extra for 2 salad dressing and two nacho cheeses. If this would have been my first experience with Greeks, it would definitely be my last. Depending on how this is resolved it still may be my last.
… more
Rhapsody
There is no sauce on 95% of the pizza. I don’t know what happened to Greeks I used to enjoy the food when I last had it a few years ago. But lately they have decided to be cheap about the pizza sauce and use it so sparingly, that it shouldn’t even be called pizza anymore, it should be called cheese bread.
… more
Timothy Oliver
I ordered a slice and a can of Coke. The drink options are limited but the slice of pizza was tasty. I had the sausage and bacon. It was just coming out of the oven so my weight wasn’t long. This place is very accessible. There are a lot of high school kids there as the high school was just a few blocks away so this makes a great stop on the way home. There’s nothing fancy here. It appears to be family-owned and operated. It’s everything you want in a neighborhood pizza joint. No complaints. I would definitely stop in again for a slice of pizza or even a whole pizza to go.
… more
Mama RN
The food is undebatebly good! no question with. But, I want to raise this concern to the manager/owner as he was not there during that time. I picked up my order tonight and this cashier staff, white mid-age man didn’t treat young boy kitchen staff respectfully. He was disrespectful towards him and cussed him in front of a customer over a non-sense reason. That is not acceptable. Greek’s Pizzeria Main St. Carmel.
… more
Jason Adams
Oh my goodness!!!!! This place is AWESOME!!!! Some of the BEST pizza I’ve ever had!!! Melts in your mouth!! Fresh flavor!! Sweet and Fresh Sauce!!!!! Mmmmmmmmm
… more
Jeramy Madlung
This has a cool old school pizzaria feel, with games like Pacman, Galaga, and more. TV’s playing sports. They do serve beer. The stix were great! The pizza was also really good. I might ask for some of the garlicky butter that they put on the stix to be put on the edge crust of the pizza, I think that would be a small upgrade to put it over the top. The service was on point, our waiter was very attentive, he seemed to be running the whole show and knew exactly how to take care of people. They also started selling donuts and we tried one. They were great, just like some of my home town favorites.
… more
Duane Johnson
Last night was my first experience at Greek Pizza. My wife and I came at 6:00pm for dinner and we’re immediately greeted as we entered and seated by a very friendly and efficient waitress. She seated us and took or drink order and was back within minutes. We order dinner salads that were very good and a medium sausage/pepperoni pizza. When the pie arrived it was hot and covered with just the right amount of sauce, meat and cheese. It was delicious! Several times our waitress came to our table to see if we needed anything and asked how our food was. I can say I was not only impressed with the food (the crust is fantastic) put also the service. We will be back again!
… more
David Webb
Everyone has their favorite style of pizza. This is good and cheesey great sauce, great cheese and great varity of toppings. Good service, good location great food. Give it a try. If this is helpful, click thumbs up below
… more
Matt Mc3
Pizza and breadsticks are so good! It might not look like the best looking place around but they definitely know how to make a pizza that has all the things you want. Sauce is on point, pizza dough is so crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. It’s going a be a regular place for me from now on!
… more
Jason Rose
I’ll have a large half mushroom with breadaticks, 2 cups of cheese, and two cokes. .Could I have the second cup of cheese…could I have the cups for the drink..oh my the pizza looked like it fell off the roof!
… more
… View more