Handcrafted cocktails & New England–style seafood are served at this buzzy, beach-themed eatery. Based on 92 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$$
Address:
305 S Mill St, Aspen, CO 81611
Phone: (970) 925-1797
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Caleb Hill
Quiet place with good vibes. I’ve been to Maine and eaten fresh lobster rolls and these were on point for being served in CO! Lobster chowdah was on the soupy side but it was very enjoyable as well. We ate at the bar and service was good.
… more
Robert Foltz
Went during fall right as they were closing for the off season. Service was good, food was delicious, and the best part of all was the atmosphere. It’s located by this cobblestone path lined with trees. The outdoor area was completely open, and made for a very unique and modern Colorado atmosphere. We sat near the cobblestone path, which features a water fountain show, which was honestly some of the best entertainment. Kids splashing, the occasional texter accidentally gets soaked by not paying attention, and dogs playing in the water. Made for great people watching.
… more
Victor Wang
Amazing delicious oysters with great seafood dishes. Love the ambiance and the service was friendly and fast.
… more
Tiffany Dahlberg
Good Peruvian chicken and seafood linguine. Lovely outdoor setting.
… more
Andrew Saluti
Had reservation at 815 but we weren’t seated until 845. The host was not at all apologetic and seemed annoyed that we kept asking if our table was ready. They charged us 5 dollars for the bread which we thought was inappropriate given that it’s only bread and we didn’t get compensated for waiting half an hour. They did eventually take that charge off but we had expected something a little more for the time we wasted. There’s much better place in town that give customers a little more respect and aren’t as pricey. Enjoyed the food but would never come back.
… more
Elliott Wynkoop
My experience here was less then I expected given its reviews. The food to me was incredibly overpriced for what you got, and the seafood I had was just terribly bland in flavor. One of my favorite sandwiches on the planet is a good lobster roll, so stopping in here for lunch that was the perfect thing for me to get. The french fries were mediocre, the pickles were great, and the lobster almost seemed fake. Just had no flavor. usually the sauce helps to back it up, but it was watered down and just dripped out also with no flavor.
… more
Reilly Bell
First round of drinks, we were having a great time and dancing. We went to get a second drink, and we waited for exactly 20 minutes with still no response from either female bartender. Our male friends were served right away, and when we tried to get her attention, she said, “byeee.” It was extremely rude and condescending. We tried to tell a bouncer what had happened and he laughed in our face. While we were incredibly happy with the atmosphere and the dj, this could have been easily avoided.
… more
Suzy Hampton
Quaint little hole in the wall place with a quiet atmosphere. Thought there would be a wider seafood selection on the menu, however the salmon and fried polenta was delicious. A little pricey for the portion size.
… more
Scott Wolfe
We were disappointed with the Grey Lady. Billed as a seafood restaurant with fresh oysters daily, there were no oysters within a thousand miles from here! Limited menu, the only seafood was salmon and fish & chips. Settled for a five ounce “rib eye,” which doesn’t exactly cut it after a full day of skiing. Brussel sprouts and lobster wedge were excellent. Uninspired decor, empty on a Friday night.
… more
Caroline Berend
38.00 for a lobster roll is ridiculous! It has MP on the menu and we didn’t ask. That was our first mistake. My crab cakes were the worst I have ever had ANYWHERE. Some of these reviews have to be made up that are 5 star. Been on vacation for 6 days so far and this is the worst food I have eaten.
… more
… View more