Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
Address:
30 New York Ave, Sound Beach, NY 11789
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Thembisa Morris
The Mango salsa Salmon is so good I was highly impressed. The atmosphere and the service was very warm and inviting. I will totally recommend Hartlin
… more
Sharon Cares
Atmosphere was nice in the front dining room. The waitstaff were wonderful. Very cozy atmosphere. The bar room was packed with happy labor day folks. It’s a beautiful old bar & a good ol’ country inn. Menu has a good variety for all ages & appetites. The building is old & the bathrooms tiny, but CLEAN & STOCKED.
… more
Margaret Sempey
My husband and I went to lunch here for the 1 st time. The place has a cozy and comfortable feeling to it. Our waitress Moreen was awesome. The food was good and reminded me of a family type meal. Will definitely think about a return visit. Pleasantly surprised.
… more
Bill Murphy
Good value. Good service. Ordered a dinner special that was a bit too salty for my taste. Our server Lauren took it right back with a smile and brought me a different dish which was very good. Highly recommend. I’ll be back.
… more
Karen Lee
I love this hidden gem! Great food, great service & feels like I’m away & visiting the local restaurant. I think I’ve tried all of the weekly and specials & enjoyed every one of them!
… more
Pamela smith
Really nice lunch/dinner. Excellent food! Only 1 waitress on, so a little slow. But we were not in a rush. Place reminds us of an off the beaten path restaurant in New England. Will definitely return.
… more
Stephen Sussman-Fort
Great food, expertly prepared, and simply delicious. I had the chicken francaise, and my wife had raspberry duck; both were outstanding. Service was friendly, prompt, and professional. Hartlin Inn gets my highest recommendation.
… more
michael schaefer
Service is attentive and they try hard. The food is what you expect, good home style comfort food for a good price .The room is alittle bright With glass over the table cloths so don’t expect cozy and romantic. It is a great place for what it is.
… more
A Gubernick
The food wasfantastic. Very delicious. The staff was friendly and knowladgable with the menu. They really gave us great Irish hospitality. And the prices are fair. A great experience. My wife and I would recommend the Hartlin inn to anyone.
… more
Ryan McCarrick (Ryan)
Tuesday is Prime Rib night! Very nice little restaurant with a bar (or bar with a restaurant )
… more
… View more