Hickory Pit Menu – McHenry, IL

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : McHenry, IL

Smoked meats with a choice of sauces, burgers & sandwiches are turned out in casual quarters. Based on 653 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

Hickory Pit 60051

Address:
3102 West, 3102 IL-120, McHenry, IL 60051

Phone:

Website:

Menu

Starters
Hickory Fries
Choice of brisket, pulled pork or chicken hand cut fries, cheese wiz, bacon, scallions & bbq sauce
$9.95
Pit Burgers
All American $9.25
Hickory $10.25
Brunch $11.25
All California $11.25
Southwest $11.25
Black & Bleu $11.25
Cow Meats Pig $11.25
Desserts
Pecan Pie
Brownie
$3.95
Meats
Pulled Pork $10.25
Sliced Brisket $11.50
Chopped Brisket $11.50
Hot Links $10.25
Pulled Chicken $10.25
Pick Two $14.75
Pick Three $18.25
The Feast $25.50
Baby Back Ribs $16.75
Roasted Chicken $12.15
Combo Half Ribs & Half Chicken $25.50
Chipolłe Maple
Hickory Sweet
Spicy Mustard
Alabama White
Piedmont Vinegar
Signature Sandwiches
Pork N Slaw $11.25
Buffalo Chicken $11.25
The Boss $11.25
Sloppy Joe $11.25
Tacos
Brisket $3.00
Pulled Pork $3.00
Pulled Chicken $3.00
Buffalo Chicken $3.00
Sides
Mac In Cheese $2.00
Baked Beans $2.00
Fresh Cut Fries $2.00
Corn Bread Muffin $2.00
Potato Salad $2.00
Sweet Potato Fries $2.00
Coleslaw $2.00
Fountain Soda $2.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

D “Juanito” H
I have been to a lot of BBQ places with different dollar signs around this country, but I was pleasantly surprised by this little place. It is simple, order the food and they will bring it to you and the BBQ is way beyond my expectations. I tried the ribs, great rub and tenderness, the chicken, even the breast piece is juicy and flavourful with rosemary, and the briskets, you can actually taste the smokey hickory immersed into the meat…Outstanding. I will definitely skip the pretentious lines at Carson’s and Chicago Q and drive 1.5 hrs to this place for a feast. These people knows what real BBQ is. Only one suggestions, make the hot BBQ source hotter!

… more

john scott
I was doing an errand in McHenry and came across this great place for a meal. It is easy to find, has good parking, and wow really tasty! The weekly vegi special for one of the sides was really great. Not what I would normally pick but ssooo glad I did . It is really good . The place was clean and it’s not super big but still lots of seats. My pulled pork sandwich was cooked just right, it was a good portion, and came with 2 sides. The cornbread muffin was a good choice but I could have used a little honey or maybe some honey butter. It did come with some butter though. The staff was very friendly and helpful. This place is now saved as one of my favorites! PS they have pulled pork Tacos that I am excited to try on my next visit!

… more

jason anhock
Midwestern boomers version of BBQ. Might as well have gone to Arby’s, the brisket tasted like somebody pour liquid smoke in the oven for 6 hours. Pulled pork was almost average for some bites, and like a mcrib on others, and I don’t mean that in the fanboi way. The pulled pork tacos would have been the star(?) of this middle school talent show had they warmed the corn tortillas. I’m not even sure what the problem is with the Mac and cheese, but when my 13 year old won’t finish a side of it, I’ll assume it’s as tasty as the corn bread muffin… I won’t ask for a refund, please use that to improve, as I see some potential, it’s just poorly executed.

… more

Nicole Skehan
I loved the food here. It was so delicious and full of flavour. So filling too!

… more

Anthony Miraldi
Sad day 5/14/21.

… more

Suraya Gabel
generous portions of mouthwatering options of fantastic bbq!

… more

Lisa Elder
Great service, incredible food. I went through the drive-thru and they had my order ready in less than 5 minutes.

… more

Cold Shoulder
I’ve eaten here about 6 or 7 times. The food is always amazing. Awesome flavor highly recommend. Chicken tacos are as amazing as they are different.

… more

Jesse Petersen
Had the pick three and was surprised how good it was. However the price went to 30 dollars from 19 which I was concerned about until I eat then I was thinking it was fine.

… more

Sandie Prickett
New in town and this place was recommended to us. It wasn’t what I was expecting, but not in a bad way. I ordered the pulled chicken sandwich and sweet potato French fries. Hubby ordered the two meats of brisket and pulled chicken with baked beans. My chicken was very tender, but really didn’t have much flavor. Thankfully the mustard BBQ sauce was quite tasty! I enjoyed that. Brisket was very good. Nice crust, Smokey and tender. Baked beans were undercooked and a little crunchy. Would eat here again even with those minor things to give it another try.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions