Based on 442 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
Address:
601 Raritan Ave, Highland Park, NJ 08904
Phone: (732) 572-6744
Website: http://www.highlandpizzanj.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
A S
We just ordered from here for the first time. Our order: the three cheeseburger sliders and a cheese steak. We live about 25 mins away and we were testing out this place for an upcoming party we are having in the area to see if they would be good to order our party food from. Well the answer is no. The sliders were decent but the meat was a bit overcooked, dry and tasteless. The curly fries were good but a bit old tasting. If they were fresh they would have been awesome. The cheese steak, well it wasn’t really a cheese steak, it was more of a salad with meat which isn’t what we ordered. Since we don’t live that close it wasn’t worth our time trying to get a new order made and we ended up ordering a cheese steak from our local place in town. So for our first experience, it didn’t go well and we won’t be trying them again.
… more
Ron M
Highland Pizza offers an extensive menu as well as a good selection of slices. They’ve been servicing the area for many years. Good pizza and food. We like the cheese steaks, sandwiches, and salads. They use Boar’s Head meats. Generous portions. Nice that they are open late. Great service and friendly staff. Free parking.
… more
Matt Halsey
Ordered a panzarotti with pepperoni and sausage. Went to pick it up and there was inexplicably a $3 discount on my order. I didn’t question it. I get home and my panzarotti was full of sausage, giant chunks of raw onions and no pepperoni. The ticket on my order said pepperoni and sausage. So they made my food wrong and tried to pass it off on me by throwing me a measly $3 discount. This isn’t the first time they’ve screwed up my orders either and as you can see by the reviews it happens pretty often. Also the food is very hit or miss; its either really good or absolutely horrible. Bottom line is for what they charge, the variable quality and the chance of them completely screwing your order up there are far better pizzeria’s out there and this place just isn’t worth the risk.
… more
Lydia Allen
I’ve been eating from Highland Park Pizza for 2 years now and they serve THE BEST EVERYTHING!
… more
Danny Larkins
I love their white spinach pizza. It is garlicky and delicious.
… more
SO O
We used to order from Highland Pizza and we stopped for many years. A few weeks ago we started ordering pizza here again. Recently, we were reminded of the reason why we stopped eating here in the first place.
… more
R Malik
I used to love their pizza back in the High school days. Its close to HPHS and their thin Crest pizza was amazing. Quality has gone down a bit but still like their location and family friendly place.
… more
Crystal Bean
Placed an order for pick up. Food was not ready even after I was 15 minutes late to pick it up. Besides that the food was great.
… more
Marijana TheQueen
You can watch a big Tv
… more
Bryan Murphy
Pizza is ok some days… you can go in one day and get a nice cooked pizza and the next it’s not cooked well at all and the dough will be raw
… more
… View more