Relaxed Italian chain offering everything from specialty pizzas & pastas to soup & subs. Based on 163 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
232 W High St, Hicksville, OH 43526
Phone: (419) 542-7702
Website: http://www.hometownpizzaoh.com/
Hours
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Reviews
Diana Blair
Waited an hour and 40 minutes for a small pizza and cheese bread. When they finally came both were burnt and cheese bread was not even cut. Won’t be ordering again!
… more
Lisa Carr
Very good pizza! Good every single time I’ve had it, no complaints ever!
… more
Paul Keezer
2 out of 3 orders in past two months, the call in order is wrong or I have to take a set for an extra 10 min while I wait on my order. ( Look no pepperoni again shocker ). When it’s done to order it is a great pizza, but that’s on occasion.
… more
Gerald Smith
Nothing is consistent with this pizza place. Sometimes I order their weekend 2 medium 2 topping special and add stuffed crust, pay them the difference, no problem. Other times I’m told they don’t do that. Sometimes they charge extra for bacon when you already get to choose two toppings. Sometimes they don’t charge extra for bacon because YOU’RE ALREADY PAYING FOR TWO TOPPINGS. Sometimes the pizza is cut, sometimes it’s not. Sometimes it’s cooked all the way through, other times it’s really doughy and I finish it in my own oven. Sometimes you’re even double charged if you’re using a credit card. I wish they got their stuff together because it used to be a really good, consistent experience and product. In the past few years it’s been progressively worse. Keep in mind these are gripes over the past couple years but I’ve had it and I guess I’ll order from somewhere else, which is a shame.
… more
Jenna Slattery
The last couple times we have ordered from this place we have been disappointed. My husband ordered a couple weeks ago and his pizza was delivered 2 hours late with no apology or concern. Then we decided to order again and order was wrong. Asked for 3 large pizzas two pepperoni and one all meat along with three breadsticks. We were given two all meat and one breadstick. They need more adults running this place its seems to be ran all by kids. The food is good when it’s right but doesn’t seem like that happens to often.
… more
Linda Lynanheart
Dropped someone’s pizza on the floor and still served it to them I don’t know how many times they’ve done that to others but it’s highly unsanitary especially since the employees wear the shoes they work in outside in a muddy day
… more
Shelby Knight
Poor management at it’s finest. The owners ex-wife was working and was very rude. She called my mother a B**** at the end of the phone call so we will NOT be doing ANY BUSINESS with them any longer!
… more
Matthew Bennett
2 yrs ago:Best pizza joint in town. Got to try the all meat sub.
… more
Rick M
I used to buy pizza there. I ordered a Supreme pizza without onions there last night, along with 2 other pizzas. They weren’t ready when they were supposed to be- not a big deal. But, I saw the workers open the box in the back and have a discussion about it. I got my pizzas and drove home 20 miles. And guess what? It had onions on it. I feel they had a discussion about this, and gave it to me anyway, knowing it was wrong. There is nothing worse than getting home after a loooooooong day, and letting people down with something they can’t eat. I even asked the person on the phone to verify my order. Honesty always wins…the drive thru at McDonald’s is always slow, but at least they get it right.
… more
Misty Laney
It says they are open, but yet no one wants to answer the phone. Guess I’ll take my business elsewhere
… more
… View more