I Am Nacho Mama Menu – Hicksville, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Hicksville, NY

Based on 772 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

I Am Nacho Mama 11801

Address:
7 W Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801

Phone: (516) 226-0228

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Empanadas
Chicken Empanada $5.50
Ground Top Sirloin Empanada $5.50
Shrimp Empanada $6.00
Cheesy Rice Empanada $5.50
Guava & Cheese Empanada $6.00
Maduro Y Manchego Empanada $6.00
Pica Pollo (Spicy Chicken) $6.00
Nachos
Regular Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with house queso cheese sauce		 $10.00
Cauliflower Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese topped with grilled cauliflower and dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de Gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
Chicken Or BBQ Chicken Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and grilled chicken that has been marinated in a plumb tomato Cuban sauce (contains dairy) and grilled over an open wood fire. Topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
Pernil Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and slow cooked Puerto Rican style pulled pork (contains gluten) dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de Gallo, grated cheese, cema and fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Shrimp Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and grilled shrimp (prepared with dairy and eggs) dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Picanha Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and Portuguese style steak prepared over a wood fire grill dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $19.00
Ground Top Sirloin Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and ground beef dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $19.00
Griddled Queso Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and strips of toasted cheese dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Salmon Nachos
Homemade corn tortilla chips topped with black beans, house queso cheese sauce and wild caught salmon that has been grilled to perfection over a wood fire. Comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $20.50
Nacho Ribs
Mama’s grilled pork ribs served on top of nachos, dressed Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $21.00
Nacho-Sagna
A baked and layered nacho dish that’s a Latino twist on mom’s lasagna made with ground top sirloin, cheese, ranchero sauce and served “Mama’s Way”		 $18.00
Tacos A La Plancha
Chicken Tacos A La Plancha
order of two tacos made with our signature chicken (contains dairy) prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $19.50
BBQ Chicken Tacos A La Plancha
order of two tacos made with our BBQ chicken (contains dairy) prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $19.50
Shrimp Tacos A La Plancha
Two tacos made with our signature grilled shrimp (contains dairy and egg) prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $21.00
Pernil Tacos A La Plancha
Two tacos made with our signature pork (contains gluten) prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $21.00
Picanha Tacos A La Plancha
Two tacos made with our signature grilled steak prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $22.50
Ground Top Sirloin Tacos A La Plancha
Two tacos made with our signature ground beef prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $22.50
Cauliflower Tacos A La Plancha
Two tacos made with our signature grilled cauliflower prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $19.50
Salmon Tacos A La Plancha
Two tacos made with our signature salmon prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $24.00
Holy Trinity Tacos A La Plancha
Our “Holy Trinity” features one chicken, one picanha, and one pernil taco prepared inside our ground corn tortillas and griddled with cheese, pico de gallo, and Chef’s recommended sauce. Served alongside pickled radish salad, ranchero dipping sauce, rice, and black beans
 $26.00
Bandido Tacos
Bandido Tacos $18.00
Burritos
Bean Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $13.00
Cauliflower Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso, and grilled cauliflower. Comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
Chicken Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
BBQ Chicken Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
Shrimp Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Pernil Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Picanha Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $19.00
Ground Top Sirloin Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $19.00
Griddled Queso Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Salmon Burrito
Wrapped in a soft flour tortilla with cilantro lime turmeric rice, black beans, melted queso comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema dn fresh cilantro)		 $20.50
Quesadillas
Cheese Quesadilla $12.00
Chicken Quesadilla $15.00
BBQ Chicken Quesadilla $15.00
Shrimp Quesadilla $17.00
Pernil Quesadilla $17.00
Picanha Quesadilla $18.00
Ground Top Sirloin Quesadilla $18.00
Salmon Quesadilla $19.50
Cauliflower Quesadilla $15.00
Bowls
Cauliflower Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with lettuce with our grilled cauliflower, topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
Chicken Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with our signature grilled chicken (contains dairy) topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $16.00
Shrimp Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with our signature grilled shrimp (contains dairy and eggs) topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Pernil Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with our signature slow cooked pork (contains gluten) topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Picanha Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with our Portuguese grilled steak topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $19.00
Ground Top Sirloin Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with our signature ground beef topped Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $19.00
Griddled Queso Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with strips of toasted cheese comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $18.00
Salmon Bowl
Served over your choice of bedding with our signature grilled salmon comes Mama’s Way (lettuce, pico de gallo, grated cheese, crema and fresh cilantro)		 $20.50
Sandwiches
Pollo Sandwich
Our signature grilled chicken, lettuce, pico de gallo, cilantro lime sauce, sweet bell peppers grated cheese and queso sandwiched within pan de agua bread that’s been toasted with garlic mayo		 $16.00
BBQ Chicken Sandwich $16.00
Carneval Picanha Sandwich
Our signature Portuguese style wood fire grilled steak, lettuce, pico de gallo, queso and chimichurri sauce sandwiched within pan de agua bread that’s been toasted with garlic mayo		 $19.00
El Messi Pan
Argentine chorizo sandwich		 $18.00
Food Truck Favorites
Street Corn
Corn on the cob, grilled over a wood fire, topped with lime, salt, crema, a smoked paprika cheese blend, and pico de gallo.		 $10.00
Sloppy Dog
Two 100% beef hot dogs, butterflied and grilled, with mama’s slaw, guacamole, grated cheese and queso all sandwiched within pan de agua bread that’s been toasted with garlic mayo 		$16.00
Mama Cuba
Nacho average Cuban sandwich… Our signature Pernil (slow cooked Puerto Rican style pulled pork), with curtido, pico de gallo, grated cheese and queso all sandwiched within pan de agua bread that’s been toasted with garlic mayo .		 $17.00
Mama’s Ribs
Pork ribs slow cooked in beer, and lightly grilled over a wood fire with your choice of our signature homestyle salt and lime rub or BBQ sauce. Served over cilantro lime turmeric rice and black beans, or a bed of lettuce. Topped with pico de gallo and grated cheese.		 $18.00
Chef Carlos’s Creations
Nacho Cheesy Rice Balls
Three of our rice balls made with cilantro lime turmeric rice, Oaxaca cheese and a crushed corn nacho chip crust. Served with ranchero dipping sauce. (Gluten free)		 $10.50
Mexi-Cola Chicken Wings
Double fried chicken wings, served with our house Mexi-Coca-Cola sauce, sprinkled with crushed pumpkin seeds. Comes with a side of cilantro lime sauce for dipping		 $16.50
Mexi-Cola Cauliflower Wings
A vegan alternative to chicken wings, our cauliflower is double fried and served with our Mexi-Coca-Cola sauce and sprinkled with crushed pumpkin seeds. Comes with a side of cilantro lime sauce (contains dairy) for dipping.		 $16.50
Mama’s Sampler
A half order of Mexi-Coca-Cola wings, tostones (fried plantains), 2 empanadas and an assortment of dipping sauces.		 $20.00
Family Meal
Chicken Family Meal
Grilled Chicken (contains dairy)		 $61.00
Cauliflower Family Meal
Grilled cauliflower (vegan)		 $61.00
Pernil Family Meal
Slow cooked Puerto Rican style pulled pork (contains gluten)		 $71.00
Picanha Family Meal
Portuguese style steak grilled over a wood fire		 $76.00
Ground Top Sirloin Family Meal
(Ground Beef)		 $76.00
Shrimp Family Meal
Grilled shrimp (contains dairy and eggs)		 $71.00
Salmon Family Meal
Grilled salmon		 $81.00
Side Orders
Side Of Cilantro Lime Turmeric Rice $7.00
Side Of Black Beans $7.00
Side Of Griddled Queso
Slices of queso de freír, griddled and served with a slice of lime		 $7.50
Guacamole And Chips
Fresh guacamole and house corn tortilla chips		 $11.00
Box Of Chips
Box of house tortilla chips		 $6.00
Side Of Queso
Side of our house melted cheese sauce		 $5.00
Side Of Salsa $5.00
Side Scoop Of Guac $4.00
Tostones
Fried plantains dressed with garlic and salt, served with Caribbean mayo-ketchup sauce on the side		 $9.00
12 Oz Side Topping
A 12oz container of one of our topping options		 $6.50
Homemade Sauces
Crema
Traditional Guatemalan cream sauce, similar to sour cream		 $0.75
Cilantro Lime $0.75
Chipotle
Chipotle mayo sauce		 $0.75
BBQ $0.75
Queso
House queso (melted cheese) sauce		 $0.75
Nutty Coconutty
Vegan peanut sauce with a coconut milk base		 $0.75
Mojito
Garlic herb sauce		 $1.25
Chiltepe
Made from the Central American Chiltepe pepper, this is our house hot sauce. (Vegan and spicy)		 $1.25
Mayan Jade
House “green” hot sauce (vegan, medium heat)		 $1.25
Chimichurri
Argentinian style chimichurri sauce (vegan)		 $1.25
Mama’s Sauce
Signature sauce		 $0.75
Desserts
Tres Leches $9.00
Spaniard Churros $9.00
Mayan Chocolate Mousse $10.00
Zacapa Flan
Made with fresh orange zest and Zacapa; a world renowned Guatemalan rum.		 $11.00
Drinks
Mexi-Sprite $3.75
Mexi-Fanta $3.75
Mexi-Cola $3.75
Limonada Fresca
The O.G of Nacho Mama Drinks, our signature limeade made with fresh lime and cane sugar, blended to order. Top with Rosa de Jamaica (hibiscus petals) for an added burst of fruity flavor. Best enjoyed fresh!
Please note: Hibiscus petals are not recommended if you are pregnant.		 $5.00
Unsweetened Hibiscus Iced Tea
Cold brewed hibiscus ice tea (caffeine free)		 $7.00
Jamaica Mocktail
Shaken hibiscus cinnamon drink, garnished with a lime		 $8.00
Horchata
Traditional rice milk beverage made from scratch with roasted nuts, grains and spices (dairy free)		 $8.00
Mango Mama
House mango juice		 $8.00
Tamarindo
House tamarind juice		 $8.00
Cafè
Espresso $3.50
Americano $4.50
Cafe Con Miel $5.50
Latte $5.00
Cappuccino $5.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Cory K
Honestly, a bit confused at the ratings. Was looking forward to my meal after reading the reviews. Picked up, $76.58 for 2 quesadillas, ground “sirloin” nachos, and BIY tacos. Quesadillas were decent. Freshly made, okay taste. Nachos got mushy but understandable with the pick up/delivery risk. The BIY tacos were so upsetting. I have to add a post image of what was almost a meal. Mama’s sauce is just mustard. Actually mustard. The service inside was great – super friendly, and clean. Super sweet girl at counter. Ambiance if I ate there would probably be good as well. Just super underwhelmed with this takeout. Your prices DO NOT match the quality of food. I love a small mom & pop shop, but unfortunately this ain’t it. Potential for a redo when I bring my bank account back up after taking out a small loan to pay the bill.

… more

Its Iconik
Awesome food and great service – everything is made to order and we got our food literally 5 minutes after placing our order – This was on a Saturday btw! The girl up front explained everything to us if we had any questions about the food. Drinks were refreshing, food was SEASONED and delicious. The owner was a very nice man – he came around asking if everyone was good and even cleaned tables himself! It is simply remarkable to see someone as humble as him. Although the prices were a bit high – the food and service was exceptional and well worth it. We left a tip and all of the staff thanked us. You can see that the employees are happy because it translate into their work and overall vibe. Great to see a place like this not only serving delicious food but also taking care of their employees.

… more

John K
I was very pleased with the flavors of the food, atmosphere, and staff. They have a great outdoor seating area with string lights. The staff was friendly, attentive, and kind. The food came out fast and the dishes were very pretty. The food was all fresh and bursting with flavor definitely recommend!!

… more

Yael W
This place is one of a kind. Eating here will make your day. The food is downright delicious!! Definitely get the loaded nachos, chicken bowl and mango drink. Everything was jampacked with flavor!! In fact this meal made me feel like I was on vacation!!! Even the decor and ambiance is cute. As for the staff, everyone was friendly, attentive and super kind. The owner even came over to see how it was and talked to us about his food inspiration. You can tell this place values it’s customers, their opinions and experience!!! Please come and enjoy a meal here, you’ll absolutely love it.

… more

Phil Foo
The best way to put it is, it felt like nacho mama invited us to her home and cooked us lunch. The meal tasted fresh and home made. The atmosphere felt friendly and inviting, as you can see in our lovely picture . Oh, and the bathroom was CLEAN.

… more

Becky Blumenthal
Amazing family friendly environment. Great value for homemade quality food and unique recipes. I wish there was a place like this near me!

… more

Mari es mi Amor
As previously stated by other clients the reviews are misleading. The place and people there are great but the food for the price is not. I ordered a burrito that was bland and had no cheese or spice at all. I think you get a better tasting burrito from a fast food place then the one I ate here. $28 for one regular burrito and a drink.

… more

Kenny Tax (Long Island Foodies)
Can we talk about lunch!

… more

Lauren Gottlieb
The staff at the restaurant is so friendly and excited to share suggestions of items on the menu. The large servings of food is fresh and the empandas are made right in front of you. Everything looks clean with a bit of a rustic seating area that makes you feel like you’re hanging out with your friends at their kitchen table. Based on a short conversation with the person taking my order, they seem to be a small family owned restaurant that just wants to serve you delicious food.

… more

Hyperion Void
Beautiful, clean and adorable decor, everything looks like it’s from story book. It has a rustic and modern vibe. The coffee is Spanish expresso with cinnamon and is not bitter at all but has a strong flavor. The nachos were not salty and seemed to be made in house. I love the crunch and freshness of the vegetables, they were vibrant in color, well seasoned, and were proportional to the amount of nachos in the basket. The service is also fantastic, as we were always being checked up on.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch